was Matt Cassel ever a top 10 QB in any 1 year?

Was he ever a top 15?

???

?????

If not I just don't see how they can compare to one another since PFF is the best tool in the NFL to evaluate NFL players (PHIL EMERY SAID SO!!!!)

so therefore you are a hypocrite

It IS debatable because he's only done so one out of seven years.

But, he is ascending, not descending, so there is a good chance that will continue.

They compare to one another based on their limitations, not their PFF ratings.

You are being obtuse.

:hmmm:


:)

Clay gladly stated he was the 18th rated QB for PFF in 2012...but, you know, that stat rates on a cumulative basis so he was 18th rated QB after 8 games when most every other QB had 16 games worth of points.

so he'll use PFF to bash on Smith but then he'll conveniently leave out 2011 because it doesn't sell his story

just like he posted 2011 PFF for Sean Smith because it was a better indicator of what player he was than 2012 Sean Smith who started all 16 games...

he's a real genious I tell you

Wrong. They compare in no way, shape or form.

Matt Cassel is an absolute TERRIBLE comparison for Alex Smith. Awful.

Facts are facts, Hootie.

In the case of Alex Smith vs Matt Cassel, their careers are similar, their abilities are similar, the way they play football is similar.

I'm not going to list all of this shit again. None of it can be argued.

You're just being a little shitbird.

In reality the first four years of his career doesn't have anything to do with what kind of QB he is now. His last 30 starts he's put up a 96.5 QB rating. That's his most recent work. That will be more indictative of the QB his is right now then his career stat line. I don't know how many sacks he had over that span. It'd interesting to know though.

Wrong.

If you want to say Alex Smith is average, then I'll agree. He is average.

If you want to say Alex Smith compares to Matt Cassel in how they play football, or their level of play...then you're just a ****ing moron.

Remember, my track record with QB's is much, much better than yours.

He was dead last in the league this year in first downs allowed.

Now ain't that some shit?

So tell me Hootie...is Sean Smith the worst CB in the NFL, or is he the guy who was dead last in the league in first downs allowed?

Pick one!

He was sacked 44 times in 2011.

Ain't that some shit?

Well, facts are facts.

Both those male quarterbacks enjoy dinking and dunking!

In fact, one enjoys it even more!

He was on pace for 41 last season.

However, Keapernick was on pace for 35. Still shitty.

he was dead last in first downs allowed?!?! OMG

hopefully he wasn't dead last in times he brought down a runner with ankle tackles...

or dead last in smiling on the field

if he's all three of those things I think Dorsey should be fired immediately...

Actually you should. "Alex Smith vs Matt Cassel" sounds like "the people vs"-thread for this season. Sublime it would be.
Posted via Mobile Device