Yep! Print 'em!

I don't think Sims should be the winner since he was highly regarded coming out of college. Minnesota thought he was the best DT in the draft as well. That makes Sims the biggest bust of a player, but not necessarily the worst pick by Carl. Carl at least had an arguably legitimate basis for selecting Sims.

omeone like Jenkins or Siavii on the other hand, they were busts plus they were reaches. That's the height of GM ineptitude.

If we've already seen the full extent of the contribution that Ryan Sims will make to the Chiefs, he wins the prize going away as far as I'm concerned.

Trezelle Jenkins is a strong candidate, but he was taken at the end of the first round. Sims was taken with the highest draft pick Carl has ever had aside from the one he used quite successfully on Derrick Thomas (he wasn't the guy who picked Neil Smith was he?).

Percy Snow and Sly Morris are also contenders, but it's hard to put all the blame for these guys on Carl since they both lost their careers to injuries before they could demonstrate their actual playing abilities.

Ryan Sims. When you draft a #6 pick and it's a failure it is devastating.

Don't forget to add what we traded for that #6 pick when figuring the magnitude of his bust.

Yep, the Chiefs were the only team to pass on him.

All I can tell you is that Percy Snow was a sack machine on techmo-bowl! Too bad he never realized his potiential in real life :)

DT

Jenkins was the worst
Siavii the second worst
Sims the third worst

Sims was at least cast as a high first round pick by other teams so it is hard to completely fault Peterson. The real error that year was trading up to get Sims instead of taking one of the other highly rated DTs that were available that year. If we had just waited until our pick we would have had John Henderson and retained our 3rd round pick. Think about that.

Ryan Sims isnt that bad


Look who his coaches were.....


Sims deserves another shot.....

Sims. No one drafted that high should suck so completely. He's stuck it to us from day one. What a pure useless piece of shit.

DIE SIMS DIE 4321

Had a little eggnog this morning, did we?

The Siavii fiasco was worse than the Sims pick by far. Olshansky was on the board for us but Carl traded down and we missed him. Instead we got Siavii who was worthless and Wilson who likely could have been had much later. Those are serious draft blunders. Much worse than drafting the top rated player and having that player turn out to be a bust.

Man King Carl has really whiffed on DT's
2001 - Eric Downing DT R3
2002 - Ryan Sims DT R1
2004 - Junior Siavii DT R2
Add this to the recent list of DT's taken...What year was Freeman DT taken in the 2nd round?

Trezelle Jenkins.