Quote:
Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath58
(Post 6346175)
Agree to disagree then I guess. I don't see these "supports" to the foundation you're talking about.
|
I was talking about supports in temporary terms, not permanent solutions. Which is why I used the word supports.
Quote:
This was the year to begin building that foundation, and here we are 11 months later, and we're still looking at a muddy hole in the ground.
|
I don't think we'll be able to tell until 2011 whether Jackson is an actual foundation player or not, because of the nature of his position, but that's what he was brought in to be. Cassel was also brought in to be a foundation player, but they didn't put anything in place around him, so his impact was going to be limited by default. Which doesn't mean I think his play is fine or anything like that, but more on that later.
I don't think you can discount holdovers from Herm just because they're holdovers from Herm. I think Dorsey has shown he can play in this system, although hurting his knee again (if that's what happened yesterday) is troubling. Hali has been fine. Both Flowers and Carr should be starters for a long time. Guys like Gilberry and Studebaker have shown some promise. Page will hopefully come back from IR. All young players with the potential to contribute for years.
I think the defense is not far off from making huge strides (talking in personnel terms). A safety and a couple of linebackers and I could see them moving up 15 or 20 spots in 2010. Although I'm not sure what kind of job Pendergast can do. Time will tell I guess.
The offense is probably going to take longer. They had less to start with, and offense generally always takes longer. The only untouchables right now in my mind are Charles and Bowe. I think Albert's going to be fine in the long term, but as far as I'm concerned the other four spots are going to have to be filled in the next two years, and sooner better than later. I think Pope has played well enough to stay (much to my surprise, honestly). But I think they need 2 receivers, a starter and a slot - I think right now, with Bowe out, they're starting a bunch of 4s. I don't know what they have in Cassel - although the last few weeks have been bad - until they have anybody around him. I've said all along that I don't think anybody could succeed behind center here with this roster, and I believe that as much now as I did in September. The question is whether he could succeed behind the reins of a talented offense, and right now I just don't know. I'm not going to say yes, but I'm also not going to say no. Just...I don't know.
Anyway, I think they have started building the core of the team. It's just hard to see it in the face of the way they play. I think the 2010 offseason will tell us a lot more than the 2009 did, in any case. The personnel department is now completely Pioli guys, there's been a shitton of roster turnover, they have tape on
everybody, and I don't think there's any viable excuse for them not to show a great deal of improvement, both on the roster and on the field. They should be a more competitive team, fall somewhere into the league average range of 6-10 to 10-6, and then in 2011 they should be fully in the division race.
Those have been my expectations since the hire was made, and that's what they continue to be, regardless of anything that's happened in 2009.