DaWolf |
04-07-2010 03:41 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by DaneMcCloud
(Post 6658440)
So, you think that Brodie Croyle is the guy of 2006 (11.6 QB rating) and 2007 (69.9) and not the guy of 2008 (81.3) or 2009 (90.6)?
Really?
Huh. I thought QB's were supposed to improve, especially as the team around them improves.
:shake:
Brodie Croyle's got more talent in his pinkie than Cassel does in his entire doofus body. He just hasn't been able to stay healthy.
|
1) A sample size of 69 passes in 08 and 09 combined aren't going to convince me that he's significantly improved. And he's never been able to step up and prove he deserves the job in the preseason. He was handed the job and never got anything done either. Does he have more pure talent than Cassel? Of course, which is why one guy was a 4th rounder and the other a 7th rounder. But he's never shown that he can put those talents to use in a franchise QB type fashion, or that he can be an effective franchise leader.
2) Wishing Brodie would be able to stay healthy is like wishing Cassel would get rid of the ball quicker. It could happen, but I wouldn't hold my breath.
I understand the desire to want to upgrade over Cassel, but to me, Brodie has had enough shots to indicate that he's probably best suited to be a backup and will never be a difference maker at QB over a season. Sure, he may improve, but he and Cassel are the same age, so with that logic, Cassel could improve too.
If we want to talk about the potential of someone like Jimmy Clausen, then fine. But I don't think the answer to Cassel is Brodie Croyle...
|