ChiefsPlanet - Football Peyton Manning

ChiefsPlanet (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/index.php)

- Nzoner's Game Room (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/forumdisplay.php?f=1)

- -

Peyton Manning (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?t=216466)

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Meat Dragon (Post 6519407)

ok...

and that's why this shifted from Manning GOAT to Montana...

No one is talking about Brady anymore because that debate is CLOSED.

Everyone knows it...

The Colts are still going to be in the mix every year...the Patriots are going to be like the Celtics now...they'll probably win their division...and then they'll lose in the 1st or 2nd round...

They are done.

That onside kick doesn't happen...the Colts probably win. That extra possession swung the entire momentum of the game...gave the Saints a 13-10 lead before the Colts answered...the Colts go up 17-6...the Saints are playing catch up rather than the Colts...

When they went up 24-17 Manning KNEW they had to score with 3+ minutes left (which is why they were in such hurry up mode) because otherwise the Saints would march down into field goal range and just end the game in regulation...with 3 minutes and 3 TO's they had a little leeway...

A play no one talks about that really helped the Saints was when that dude got injured on 3rd and 5 and they went to an injury timeout...Manning was tearing them apart with the hurry up...that gave them a chance to regroup and call a play and have the right personnel out there...and then he throws the pick.

shouldnt the so called greatest of all time be able to kill momentum by matching score with score..im not going to listen to your circular logic of manning is the best because he is the best ive been on this site for 2 days and its already old..its no wonder you're known on this site for being a dumb ass

I'm not going to spend my day off arguing with 3 17 year old kids who were still breast feeding when Brady won his 1st Super Bowl...the same postseason where he threw 1 TD pass.

If Dwight Freeney is healthy.....the Colts win.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Meat Dragon (Post 6519419)

I'm not going to spend my day off arguing with 3 17 year old kids who were still breast feeding when Brady won his 1st Super Bowl...the same postseason where he threw 1 TD pass.

ZING ROFL

a 50% win to loss ratio in the playoffs reflects the best of all time i think

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pestilence (Post 6519423)

If Dwight Freeney is healthy.....the Colts win.

if the saints starting LT had played..

Quote:

Originally Posted by DBOSHO (Post 6519433)

if the saints starting LT had played..

He would have gotten owned by Freeney. Next topic...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pestilence (Post 6519437)

He would have gotten owned by Freeney. Next topic...

thats a clever way of opting out of an argument you start

Quote:

Originally Posted by Pestilence (Post 6519437)

He would have gotten owned by Freeney. Next topic...

proof?

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Meat Dragon (Post 6519332)

you're a joke man...you really are

even THIS site has closed the book on the Manning/Brady debate...

err....maybe. But that's primarily because Brady was out for all of 2008 and 2009 sucked for the Patriots in general, with him having a "meh" year. Meanwhile, Peyton had another good year, so memories being short...

Look, he's won four MVPs. I'm not blind to that. It's hardly like I missed that fact. Or that he has more MVPs than anyone in NFL history. Well done. Applaud. But we'll see what 2010 and beyond brings.

Quote:

have you noticed that this thread has shifted from Brady/Manning to GOAT?

Well, except for a few nujobs like yourself who can't separate their lips from Manning's rear, it's mostly about how he's NOT the GOAT. :p

Quote:

and people have finally figured out that Brady can't even sniff Manning's jock...

sorry dude...

It's over.

Which is why you spend all your time talking about it.

Look, honestly, I've always said I'd be perfectly happy with EITHER as my QB. You can tell me Manning is better, but all I see is far too many playoff choke jobs which make me REALLY happy to have Tom Brady and three rings and not Peyton adn one ring. Thanksallthesame.

Quote:

That's why all you're seeing is Montana now...people hate Manning on this site...but they can no longer chuck Brady's name out there because they realized how much of a fraud he really is when it comes to the GOAT talk...

Except for 2007 when Brady went nuts with Moss, there has never been that much talk of Brady as GOAT.

And as I said, except for you and a few others, there isn't much talk of Manning as GOAT either.

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Meat Dragon (Post 6519334)

This argument is dead.

Try to follow along.

Harrison retires.

Enter Garcon and Collie.

Suddenly both look like all-pro caliber receivers...

Hmm...

Wonder what the common denominator is?

Wayne and Clark?

Or are you honestly telling me that you think Brady has had the same caliber of WRs/TEs/RBs that Manning has had.

I note that Branch, Givens and others haven't exactly lit it up since leaving Brady's side...

if manning wasnt such a nice guy everyone in the world wouldnt be so pro-manning. the 1 SB he won its well known that his rbs/defense outplayed him but he still gets MVP and gives people reasons to be on his nuts

Quote:

Originally Posted by Amnorix (Post 6519458)

havent you heard?

its and automatic GIVEN that collie and garcon will blow when they leave indy

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Meat Dragon (Post 6519365)

If Joe Montana was a Saint for his entire career...how many Super Bowls would he have won?

So you're saying that Polian isn't good at drafting/acquiring talent? Freeney, Sanders, Wayne, Harrison, Clark, Saturday, the LT whose name I'm forgetting, Addai, James, etc. etc.

Wow, who knew.

i wish i wasnt "17" so the facts i bring up would count.