doboshow you wanna play some xbl since this clown has clearly ducked out of this conversation

well i dont know who doboshow its but ill play.

Brady lost a SB playing with the most dominating downfield threat WR this game has probably ever seen. This is the same season where all those passing/recv records were broken.

Manning was a pedestrian 25 for 38 with a TD and pick.

The Colts OL dominated the Bears, running for over 180 yards. Their defense, meanwhile, had two picks, one for a TD and held the offensively-challenged Bears (a fairly mediocre SB team, BTW) to less than 300 yards of total offense.

But yeah -- it was all Manning...

Seriously, you can't make this stuff up.

Did you watch his offensive line get dominated by the Giants DLine the entire game, or did you just not watch the game?

Given how little time he had, I thought Brady played very well. Better than Meltdown Manning likely would have.

Yep you're right. Ben Roethlisberger is better than Peyton Manning because he's won 2 SB's. :rolleyes:

Manning wins awards for being nice. <=== best argument ever!!!

I saw it, the Oline played horrible. Brady and the offense still choked.

See there are other aspects to the game than just the QB's. But you can go as far as saying that Manning prob would have thrown their defense off guard with his audbles and changing at the line etc. No one does that like Manning, not even Brady.

I can go on and say that the Colts defenses in 2002-03 etc have prevented Manning from going to more SB's than he's been in.

Eh? Bit of a nonsequitur there. I agree the OFFENSE choked because the OLine got dominated. Couldn't run the ball worth a damn and Brady had no time.

But that's Brady's fault? That's a joke, to be honest.

Did you knwo the Patriots had FORTY-FIVE (45) yards rushing that game? Average of 2.8 yards. And even though Brady was under pressure all day and sacked five freaking times, he threw ZERO picks.

How many did Manning throw the other day against the Saints when his jersey barely got dirty all day? Oh right, just the one I guess...

Yeah, like the Giants defense playing out of their minds and dominating the Patriots OLine. But Brady still scoring the late go ahead TD. And then the defense giving up the game winning drive to the Giants, including "helmet catch". But presumably Brady should've audibled to Rodney Harrison that that was coming, because that's what Peyton would have done.

Of course, none of this has resulted in anything more than one SB win for Peyton -- a game in which he had a thoroughly pedestrian performance by the way -- in his career, but that's ok. His sweat smells like roses too....

No one in competition fo rthe GOAT throws picks in key games like Manning either, certainly not Brady.

I can go on and say that the Colts defenses in 2002-03 etc have prevented Manning from going to more SB's than he's been in.[/quote]

You didn't see the Patriots 2002 defense much did you? Or '05... Or '09 for that matter. It wasn't pretty, really. No pressure on QBs and a serious problem with stopping the run.

no, him getting hurt has no relation to his defenses ability
Posted via Mobile Device

I'd give the credit to Bill Polian, who's one of the best talent evaluators in the game..

And the Colts dont? Top 3 o line in the league, Wayne, Clark, Collie, Garcon & Addai..then Freeney, Mathis, Brackett, and a highly underrated secondary..thats enough talent..Peyton just crumbles under the spotlight damn near everytime

Best part of the SB was watching mangina throw the pick to seal the loss-thats gonna leave a mark on his rep-lol

HAHA, comparing the Pats defense to the Colts is just laughable. The Pats defense had more influence on their SB victories than Brady did.

Of course nothing will change your mind. You're a Pats fan.

Switch Peyton and Tom Badass to the other team and Peyton has more SB's the Brady. not even close.

Tom put the team up with less than 2 minutes to go, and it took 2 miracles in the same play to put the giants on top.

What makes you so sure?