I’d say Priest suffers from nostalgia bias. Those times were fun. Squirmin Herman Mother****ing Sack of **** Edwards was not fun.



Jamaal would bounce that outside, had a sandwich and walked into the end zone. That was fun, but just because Jamaal didn’t do that doesn’t mean that play isn’t 6. Prime Jamaal never got caught on the outside.

If for no other reason, look at LJ before he got hurt who wrecked oussies behind that line but didn’t do ****all behind Herms line then he gets hurt and Jamaal lights the ****ing world on fire.

He did. He broke away for like a 50 yard run in the 2nd half and got caught from behind. He was stripped and whoever tackled him came up with the ball. They were the only two players within 50 yards of the ball and the Colts came up with it. Priest was probably 15-20 yards from scoring and got chased down with nobody else in sight.

On that bullshit offensive PI call on TG, we ended up missing a field goal. That’s 14 points taken off the board. We win that game fairly easily with those two plays...even without forcing a punt.

We were cursed.

Not even a question, man...

Priest eats more nachos any day any time over Charles.

Don't make me choose.

FAX

Charles for sure.

Priest was a TD machine. He timed the jump over the line so well. Jamaal was smooth as silk and had just deceptive speed. For some reason he often seemed to get tackled just before going over the goal line, which is why that TD total isn't higher. He also was prone to coughing up the ball. I think Jamaal was more talented, Priest was a better "player". I trusted Priest to always get it in. So I think I've talked myself into giving it to Priest. Seeing Jamaal behind Priest's line though, that would have been a thing of beauty. Damn, tougher than I thought.

Jamaal Returned a kick for a touchdown as well

pxwxUxNY

This is a tough one. I'm too dang nostalgic to pick JC. And Priest never played for the ****ing donx, that alone excludes JC.

i can't vote for "I've always wanted to play for the Donkies" or he would have gotten my vote.

Jamaal Charles was a beast in the Special Olympics he was faster than all those people with mobilized disabilities.

Priest.

Priest was a good back behind a great line. His gift was patience and vision. He wasn't a back like JC who could house it on any given play.

Loved Charles, too bad he got hurt so much!