No, quit it. Stop comparing Eli to Peyton. Not the same guy. Eli makes some Ryan Leaf like decisions. Lets take a look at some Career Stats.

ELI MANNING: 73.4 QB rating; AVG: 6.3 yards; 77/64 TD to INT
DAMON HUARD: 82.0 QB rating; AVG: 6.7 yards; 31/23 TD to INT

I mean freaking honestly. Stop licking Eli Mannings nuts. He's horrible. Has been horrible since coming into the league. The sad thing is he hasn't gotten ANY better since coming into the league four years ago. It's not like he's getting any better. And no I wouldn't trade Croyle for Eli. It might be a toss up, but at least Croyle is younger. Croyle has just as good of an arm as Eli, and the jury is out on if he's reeruned as Eli is in regards to throwing into triple coverage.

Eli had Toomer, Tiki Barber, Jeremy Shockey, Brandon Jacobs, Plaxico Burress. I mean come on now.

Still light years ahead of what our team is working with...

And how??? The surrounding level of talent is better, but not really at QB. The Giants don't really have a hand. Eli is #1 round talent, they have no choice to stick with him. It's a financial decision more than anything.

Eli has thrown more INTs every year since coming into the league, and his TDs or yards aren't going up. If anything, the Giants have done more in Eli's time than the Colts in Manning's time despite Eli.


:spock:

Hilarious. LMAO

Any Jessica Simpson sightings?

For all you can say about Manning if you'd rather have Brodie Croyle than him, there aren't words for that.

Cowboys offensive players are huge... thanks to Parcells

If you look at results ON THE FIELD, and not the fact that he's a Manning offspring or a #1 pick...I really think a swap of him and Croyle would be a complete toss up, if not in the Chiefs favor not to do so.

Eesh drops the pick.

Nice drop of the easy INT.

When Croyle makes the playoffs or wins a playoff game let me know.

I'll take Brodie over Eli as of this point. Eli's prone to INT's, especially in his 4th year in the league.

Eli exactly haven't shown me that he's worthy of being number one. The Chargers made a excellent decision to trade him to the Giants for more picks.

Eli's overrated, always have been, always will.

Again, Croyle can't do everything by himself, just to let you know.

Man those are some homer ****in posts.......obviously Brodie Croyle who's 0-6 and shown a lot of nothing is already better than about 20 of the starting QB's in the league according to some here.