What other answers do you need, specifically?

Geno is MUCH better as a passer and has plus mobility. Their ceilings aren't comparable.

Have you noticed that Geno's stats don't reflect a thing that you are saying? Don't believe my lying eyes? LOL

He is an inconsistent rookie, but it's not like he hasn't flashed the ability to be a good player.

63% 256 1-1 in first game
331 2:2 and a rushing td against Buffalo
80% 200 yards 3td 0 int against Atlanta
233 1:1 and a rushing td against New England (and a player of the week award)
64% 219 1:1 and a rushing td against Oakland

The kid has been impressive in some weeks, the trouble is that he comes back the next wee and looks so bad he makes you forget he was ever good.

That is Cherry Picking at it's finest. Good lord.

Thanks for the effort though.

It's cherry picking to show his stats from his teams wins?

He is a rookie, consistency is a rarity among rookies.

Last year made people forget that.

What you want to see is flashing of the players upside...things to build on. You also want to see mistakes so you can formulate a game plan based on his strengths and weaknesses. Geno has shown that he can perform at a high level if put into position to do so. Even with a talentless team.

9 TD's, 20 INT's, 55% for completions. Those are turrible numbers for a QB, rookie or otherwise.

Please explain.

Actually, now that I think about it, I'm taking Kiko Alonso 1 overall if we are re-drafting.

He's going to be a top 5 MLB for the next 10 years in the NFL.

No doubt...but lets also factor in his 4 rushing touchdowns to be fair.

13 scoring td scoring plays, 20 throws that ended in turnovers.

I was gonna list him with Vaccaro and Mingo, but didnt want to hear the whole "yeah, they should reach a full round dummy" responses.

Vaccaro would be magical in this defense.

Are you really going to try and compare him to Luck and RG III? REALLY?

I have a small task for you.

Without including guys drafted in 2012, list the quarterbacks that won 6 or more games as rookies.

See ya in a little bit.

Let me get this right....not Geno..right?

Yeah, cause I've done that.