Because all cornerbacks do is pick off passes?
That's brilliant.

In 56 starts, he has 5 INT's.
Wanna guess how many picks Carr had over the first 56 starts of his career?
Don't worry, I'll wait.

I hate Alex Smith as much as the next guy. I love Geno, I almost cried when we traded for Alex Smiff but it is what it is. Can you atleast agree that its atleast a pretty good contract? Atleast this isnt revis money.

Thank god we didn't keep Carr, he sucked last year.

I love it. Matt Miller and Incarcerated Bob are going at it on twiter.

Thats why he is a #2 and not a #1.

The post claimed Sean Smith had good hands.

He doesn't.

He also sucks at other aspects of his job.

Carr isn't the 1 in Dallas?

Carr had a good year for having to cover real WRs unlike the jokes in the AFC West

Claiborne is probably the no.1 in Dallas.

You're oversimplifying what creates a dropped pass.
It's not a good hands/bad hands binary.

You act as though catching a ball doesn't also involve concentration.
Bowe has good hands, but he has bad habits that contribute to his drops.

Same is true of Smith.
Sean Smith will make an extraordinary interception from time-to-time.
Because he has GOOD HANDS. He struggles with consistent concentration and focus when he tries to bring a ball in.

And there's more to being a good corner than picking passes off anyway.

I'll answer for you since you dodged my question.
Brandon Carr had 6 INT's through his first 56 starts (1 more than Smith at the same stage).
Dallas should cut him now, right?

Far far FAR worse.

The DeVito signing is an abortion on all levels.

Then the Cowboys severly overpaid for a #2 CB.

He was the worst CB in football in 2011 for those "other" reasons.

and miami fans should be crying they have no secondary because they would rather spend 200 million on two WRs and two LBs based of their one season samples

so they can run their mouths all they want their starting CB is nolan ****ing carroll and the LBs they overpaid for still dont hold a candle to ours

Andy Reid is doing the same shit he did with the Eagles. Overpay a bunch of free agents and hope it works out. I can't think of many teams that have won using this tactic since the salary cap was implemented. I can also think of many who wound up in cap hell trying.