A boatload of sports critics are bashing Buffalo though, worst pick of the draft so far and all. No mercy.

Why do you keep bringing up Alex Smith?

I don't care about Alex Smith. If Alex Smith is viewed by this team as a stop gap, fantastic. I have no issue with a young, talented QB learning the ropes while Alex Smith takes the sacks.

I would actually PREFER it over just throwing our rookie into the fire.

I've been saying it ever since the trade was made.

You, and others continue to make up arguments that don't exist.

Dude. Geno started as a whisper, then somebody agreed, then more people agreed, and then it became a cult. I doubt the majority of Genoites watched him play a single game and, at most, watched some highlights. Highlights don't tell the whole story. EJ got the nod from the senior bowl performance (the one Geno felt too good for).

Trashing Buffalo?


Well, Manuel was infact a reach, but we don't know what he will become, so to say he's a bad player at this point is wrong.

He was however probably overdrafted.

This is looking far worse than what Pioli did.

I shut off the draft after Miami's trade; ...what did I miss from Geno?

So drafting a guy based on his Sr bowl performance is a good idea now?

How about at 2.2? Oh crap, that is gone again!:banghead:

Considering what he had done the last 28 games or so yes.

We cant search right now but when they benched Smith I stated I thought it was a mistake. That was before I knew he was coming to KC so yea I thought he was good last year.

Not drafted... .. .

Geno didn't start as a whisper. The Geno fan base grew here because as the months went on, it became more and more clear that Geno was the top QB prospect.

Back in January, we had Cults for Bray, Wilson and Barkley. The threads speak for themselves.

At the end of last year, this forum was torn in 5 different directions on who the top QB was.

So we dont trade for Alex draft a LT at 1.1 and pray there is a developmental QB at 2.2?

Who would be your starting QB? Would Geno be ready? I say no and always have thought no.

Exactly.

Maybe he was overdrafted. It seems that way right now.

But hey, at least they're addressing the situation. And if he turns out to be a good player like Buffalo thinks he will be, then where he was drafted won't matter.

I don't see Alex winning playoff games here because IMO, there's no way KC wins the division with Peyton Manning around and thus forcing KC to play on the road in a WC against any of these teams: Pitt/Balt/Houston/Bengals/Colts.