ChiefsPlanet

ChiefsPlanet (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/index.php)
-   Nzoner's Game Room (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/forumdisplay.php?f=1)
-   -   Football Off-season WR possibilities (https://chiefsplanet.com/BB/showthread.php?t=351517)

O.city 01-04-2024 09:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tredadda (Post 17318039)
Elite players produce regardless of who’s throwing the ball. No one is calling Brown elite. He would still do better here with this QB than anywhere else. MVS always had issues with drops and it didn’t get fixed here. He and Brown are nowhere near the same player.

Quote:

Originally Posted by penguinz (Post 17318040)
Brown had a QB that couldn't throw the ball and then multiple, some barely even backup level, QB's in a dumpster fire organization throw him the ball.

Not remotely the same thing as MVS.

I'm not comparing him to MVS, or that wasn't my intention there. Just using him as an example that just saying "we have Mahomes he'll produce here" isn't necessarily a given.

BigCatDaddy 01-04-2024 09:13 AM

Any thoughts on what Allen might get. I think Hopkins is the only half way decent comp (age/production) and he got 2 for 26 or something along those lines. Thielen got 3 for 24 and balled out.

O.city 01-04-2024 09:14 AM

Allen misses alot of games with soft tissue stuff, that usually gets worse wiht age.

I'd say he might be a 2/24 guy or that's what I'd wanna pay him here.

OnTheWarpath15 01-04-2024 09:16 AM

I continue to be amazed that people see how this current WR room has been built with draft picks and reclamation projects - and then want to continue to go down that road.

There's no need for us to be in the "revive someone's career" business. Let someone else take that risk.

It's not gonna be easy - but Veach's job is to find someone through the draft, FA and/or trade that will be a difference maker, not a question mark.

O.city 01-04-2024 09:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by OnTheWarpath15 (Post 17318048)
I continue to be amazed that people see how this current WR room has been built with draft picks and reclamation projects - and then want to continue to go down that road.

There's no need for us to be in the "revive someone's career" business. Let someone else take that risk.

It's not gonna be easy - but Veach's job is to find someone through the draft, FA and/or trade that will be a difference maker, not a question mark.

I actually think Brown would be a nice fit here, but a good fit at 14 million a year not at 20 million.

That just seems wild for a guy that's had 1 good season, but FA is FA.

BigCatDaddy 01-04-2024 09:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 17318045)
Allen misses alot of games with soft tissue stuff, that usually gets worse wiht age.

I'd say he might be a 2/24 guy or that's what I'd wanna pay him here.

Ehh.. missed a bit last year and has been relatively healthy for the most part but I think you are in the ball park on salary. He is just a zone killer.

https://www.pro-football-reference.c...A/AlleKe00.htm

duncan_idaho 01-04-2024 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 17318035)
Would Hopkins cost 20 million a year? Does context not matter in that one?

The disgruntled WR who got drafted early and hasn't lived up to it now wants to be paid when he's had 1 above average year. I don't think I'm that excited about that.

Of course it matters.

I wouldn't care that Hopkins was on his 3rd team in 3 years. It's a weird random fact that has nothing to do with the player and whether I want him or he fits.

Any guy that the Chiefs would be trading for would, in all likelihood, be able to be slapped with a "disgruntled" tag. Terry McLaurin is "disgruntled" and tired of losing in Washington while a revolving door of garbage QBs shot-put the ball in his general vicinity. If Justin Jefferson forces a trade out of Minnesota, it would qualify.

That wouldn't be a factor I'd be worried about in acquiring him.

D.J. Moore was disgruntled in Carolina. Stafon Diggs is disgruntled, it seems, generally. Tyreek Hill was apparently disgruntled in Kansas City.

I'm not even all-in on Brown. It's the option that makes the most sense and seems the most likely to me, as of today. It's a move you can make, with enough upside it ends up as a value move, and the floor is high enough to have it only be a mild overpay. I like the range of outcomes compared to the investment cost.

O.city 01-04-2024 09:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigCatDaddy (Post 17318051)
Ehh.. missed a bit last year and has been relatively healthy for the most part but I think you are in the ball park on salary. He is just a zone killer.

https://www.pro-football-reference.c...A/AlleKe00.htm

He's so good though. **** I might go 3 for 55 and guarantee 35 of it. But it's risky.

duncan_idaho 01-04-2024 09:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 17318038)
I'd give up my first and pay a guy 25 million a year and Hardman a minimal deal vs pay Hollywood 20 million plus a year.

Yeah, I get that. I just don't agree that Aiyuk + Hardman is better than, say,

Marquise Brown or Mike Evans + Emeka Egbuka or Adonai Mitchell + a solid starter with the leftover cap space.

OnTheWarpath15 01-04-2024 09:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 17318056)
He's so good though. **** I might go 3 for 55 and guarantee 35 of it. But it's risky.

I'd rather take the risk on someone like Allen or Evans that has PROVEN to be a top notch talent than to spend on a guy we have to make excuses for to justify the signing.

If Veach is aggressive and it just doesn't work out, fine.

But to half-ass it with guys with question marks - no thanks, we've seen that movie before.

OnTheWarpath15 01-04-2024 09:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by duncan_idaho (Post 17318054)
Of course it matters.

I wouldn't care that Hopkins was on his 3rd team in 3 years. It's a weird random fact that has nothing to do with the player and whether I want him or he fits.

Any guy that the Chiefs would be trading for would, in all likelihood, be able to be slapped with a "disgruntled" tag. Terry McLaurin is "disgruntled" and tired of losing in Washington while a revolving door of garbage QBs shot-put the ball in his general vicinity. If Justin Jefferson forces a trade out of Minnesota, it would qualify.

That wouldn't be a factor I'd be worried about in acquiring him.

D.J. Moore was disgruntled in Carolina. Stafon Diggs is disgruntled, it seems, generally. Tyreek Hill was apparently disgruntled in Kansas City.

I'm not even all-in on Brown. It's the option that makes the most sense and seems the most likely to me, as of today. It's a move you can make, with enough upside it ends up as a value move, and the floor is high enough to have it only be a mild overpay. I like the range of outcomes compared to the investment cost.

The only thing these WR's have in common with Hollywood is the "disgruntled" tag.

They are all in a class well above.

O.city 01-04-2024 09:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by duncan_idaho (Post 17318059)
Yeah, I get that. I just don't agree that Aiyuk + Hardman is better than, say,

Marquise Brown or Mike Evans + Emeka Egbuka or Adonai Mitchell + a solid starter with the leftover cap space.

Why wouldn't Mike Evans get 25 plus a year? With the amount of money out there, if Brown is getting 20, there's no chance you get Evans for less than 25, he's a top 5ish WR.

If I can get Egbuka, just draft him, put him outside, sign a mid tier FA WR and go forward. Dont' overspend on it, play the kids and deal with it.

O.city 01-04-2024 09:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by duncan_idaho (Post 17318054)
Of course it matters.

I wouldn't care that Hopkins was on his 3rd team in 3 years. It's a weird random fact that has nothing to do with the player and whether I want him or he fits.

Any guy that the Chiefs would be trading for would, in all likelihood, be able to be slapped with a "disgruntled" tag. Terry McLaurin is "disgruntled" and tired of losing in Washington while a revolving door of garbage QBs shot-put the ball in his general vicinity. If Justin Jefferson forces a trade out of Minnesota, it would qualify.

That wouldn't be a factor I'd be worried about in acquiring him.

D.J. Moore was disgruntled in Carolina. Stafon Diggs is disgruntled, it seems, generally. Tyreek Hill was apparently disgruntled in Kansas City.

I'm not even all-in on Brown. It's the option that makes the most sense and seems the most likely to me, as of today. It's a move you can make, with enough upside it ends up as a value move, and the floor is high enough to have it only be a mild overpay. I like the range of outcomes compared to the investment cost.

One of those disgruntled WR's has 1 1k yard season and forced his way off a perennial winning franchise.

I'd say that's not really anything like the others, but we are talking WR's so they're pretty much always disgruntled.

If Jefferson wants out, yeah, send them 2 1's and pay him and move on.

RunKC 01-04-2024 09:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 17318050)
I actually think Brown would be a nice fit here, but a good fit at 14 million a year not at 20 million.

That just seems wild for a guy that's had 1 good season, but FA is FA.

Don't get the Hollywood Brown disapproval.

MVS had Rodgers and Mahomes and still couldn't ever produce consistently. Watson was on a team with Tom Brady and couldn't even get on the field. Was even on a PS.

Hollywood Brown was a key component to Lamar winning MVP. Had 21 TD's in 3 years at Baltimore and 7 in 2 years with a carousel of QB's about half the time.

He's obviously a good player that produces. He also fits the scheme really well. They need a burner to replace MVS. If it isn't him then who? Bc Duvernway and Mooney is pretty much doing what we have been doing.

They need to go after a big fish FA

OnTheWarpath15 01-04-2024 09:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by O.city (Post 17318063)
Why wouldn't Mike Evans get 25 plus a year? With the amount of money out there, if Brown is getting 20, there's no chance you get Evans for less than 25, he's a top 5ish WR.

If I can get Egbuka, just draft him, put him outside, sign a mid tier FA WR and go forward. Dont' overspend on it, play the kids and deal with it.

Spotrac has Evans' projected contract at 4/$96M.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:00 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.