#1 and #3 won't happen as it is an offensive game in the NFL. That is good for us now that we will have PMIII starting.:D

#2 definitely agree

#4 Ok, no real opinion

#5 keep it as is

I would like to see one challenge a game if you felt there was an obvious face mask or hold or PI that could change the game that was or wasn't called.

If getting more calls right is an improvement, then yes. C'mon...
An overturned call is one they got (eventually) got right that would have been wrong. They usually aren't too many complaints about those.

:rolleyes:
Pretty much everything is a judgment call. Especially if you're going to allow for things like 'incidental' contact that doesn't really impact the play.

Add the targeting rule that college has and make it reviewable. Make everything challengeable including penalties.

The league had meetings to specifically "emphasize" these types of rules. The league can just as easily erase that and they should. If there's gray area, then I'd rather let the play play out instead of giving away free plays to the offense like candy.

Make more of the offensive penalties include loss of down. Most penalties on the defense give the offense too much of an advantage. Make DPI review-able somehow. Add a targeting rule to eliminate leading with the head in all situations. On one hand we are told to be amazed at the athletic ability of these players and on the other, we are told that it all happens too fast. Garbage, players know they are targeting and leading with their heads.

The game has swung way too much in favor of the offense. Running backs can put their head down and run into someone, they can grab the face mask of a defender and use it to leverage them out of the way. The intentional grounding rule is a joke; if the QB can't get away or find someone to throw the ball then it should be treated as a sack.

I don't like the rules about a catch, if the ball touches the ground, not a catch. If the ball moves when you land out of bounds, not a catch. If you catch the ball, get two feet on the ground and cross the goal line the play is over, TD.

The ground can cause a fumble if the ball carrier goes to the ground without being contacted by a tackler. “The ground cannot cause a fumble” is one of the dumber incorrect clichés we’ve been bequeathed by idiot sportscasters.

But, yeah, the catch rule is a mess.

I’d make it illegal to pass the ball every play when you have a lead. Maybe that will help Andy out some??

I'd be happy if they'd just make it a level playing field when it comes to penalties.

I'm about done with the preferential treatment.

Yes this. ^^ Challenge all calls. Maybe there will be pressure on the officials to not make shitty calls or purposeful make game changing calls. Hell, how about challenge any play such as the ones the official **** tards don't call. Like the one where Kelce got speared helmet to helmet and they didn't even bat their eyes.

I’m skeptical that anyone would sit through a five hour game.

I also don't understand why "clocking the ball" isn't intentional grounding. The QB is still between the tackles and the ball is not thrown at the line of scrimmage or towards a receiver.

Agreed. But I am sure they have some BS reason why it isn't. Probably that it would "kill the dramatic drive" because time would run out and ratings would really dip in the last 45 sec of the game once the fanbase learns they have no timeouts.:D

if kicking the ball out of bounds on the back end of the end zone is not a penalty, kickers should be able to coffin corner kick again. (would lessen the violent hits, plus reward the kicking team for such good placement.)

accident or not, defender must be removed if player 'is confirmed' as having a concussion.

absolutely love the mittens idea ROFL

all plays should be review-able, including early whistles that void plays reviewability. :D

forward progress must be a three second count :thumb:

offensive holding should be 5 yards and loss of down. :D

When they do they should get a week off and a $50K fine.