Smith's last 3 years have led to playoff births. Ryan won 4 games last year and missed the playoffs. Also, how many 2 win teams has Ryan took over and led to a wildcard birth? I'll wait.

ROFL

He took a 4-12 team as a rookie to the playoffs. What did Alex do as a rookie?

The guy has played in 3 less seasons and has 50 more TD passes... in before "lol fantasy football!!!!!"

QB WINZ

What have you done for me lately? If we're going to judge Alex Smith off of 2005, then **** it, I'm out.

Also, lol @ you citing Matt Ryan's touchdown passes to the likes of Julio Jones, Roddy White, Tony Gonzalez, and Harry Douglas. Damon Huard would win a playoff game with that offense.

Also, if you think Alex Smith led this team to the playoffs you're ****ing drunk, stupid, and deserve aids laced rape.

I'm playing by the same rules. If we're judging off of team success, I can play that game as well. Smith exceeds Ryan in both categories IMO.

Bunch of deep threats that Alex wouldn't be able to get the ball to.

I believe Alex Smith led this team to the playoffs. He put up over 500 passes with 7 turnovers. When it comes to managing a game, there are few who are better.

ROFLROFLROFL

Alex's team success = QBing a team that has finished above .500 3 ****ing times. Ya... hes far better than Matt Ryan when it comes to that!!!

Ignoring the fact that Smith actually has a pretty damn good deep ball. But of course when you're only regurgitating the same old anti-Smith talking points around here, Smith's ability as a passer becomes an inconvenience.

Sure proved that last Sunday.

Finishing over 500 3 times in the last 3 years. Like I said, I don't give a frog's fat ass what he did during the Bush administration. He's clearly a different QB now than he was.

Same QB he's always been.

You can't throw deep balls when the defensive line is teabagging you 1.5 seconds after snapping the ball.

Which didn't happen on his interceptions. Nice try, I guess.

Just a ****ing stupid statement. Look at the statistics. Look at the winning percentage. Watch the tape. I get that it's the cool thing to hate him these days, but he's genuinely one of the last things we need to worry about right now.

If he has a number 1 receiver, those interceptions don't happen. I guarantee if Dwayne Bowe plays, those passes at least get knocked down. When you give a guy a bunch of brokedick offensive linemen and throw in some brokedick wide receivers, chances are things aren't going to be very pretty.

Don't feel like watch 10 years of shit QB play knowing that that puke is going to be in KC for the next 3 years.

Indeed.

Then look at his stat progression.

Spoiler alert: Andy Reid knows more about QB success than you do. And Clay. And any other Ron Jaworski wannabe around here who enjoys getting their esophagus punctured by Geno Smith.

Only 49.52% believe that Stafford is better than Smith.

Good....God.

THROWS OF 20-PLUS YARDS IN 2011 (includes playoff games)
(From Pro Football Focus)
AARON RODGERS, Packers (16 games): 129.1 QB rating
33 of 66, 1,264 yards, 14 TD, 1 INT
MATT SCHAUB, Texans (10 games): 125.3
14 of 37, 499 yards, 5 TD, 0 INT
TONY ROMO, Cowboys (16 games): 123.8
32 of 61, 1,166 yards, 13 TD, 2 INT
ALEX SMITH, 49ers (18 games): 111.4
21 of 51, 723 yards, 6 TD, 2 INT
MATTHEW STAFFORD, Lions (17 games): 107.8
34 of 83, 1,187, 12 TD, 4 INT
DREW BREES, Saints (18 games): 107.3
44 of 86, 1,187 yards, 20 TD, 6 INT
ELI MANNING, Giants (20 games): 103.2
49 of 123, 1,675 yards, 15 TD, 7 INT
CAM NEWTON, Panthers (16 games): 92.6
33 of 89, 1,149 yards, 7 TD, 4 INT
PHILIP RIVERS, Chargers (16 games): 91.4
28 of 75 935 yards, 12 TD, 6 INT
TOM BRADY, Patriots (19 games): 87.7
23 of 73, 746 yards, 10 TD, 4 INT
JOE FLACCO, Ravens (18 games): 81.8
25 of 88, 816 yards, 8 TD, 3 INT
BEN ROETHLISBERGER, Steelers (16 games): 77.5
24 of 75, 818 yards, 7 TD, 5 INT
MICHAEL VICK, Eagles (13 games): 77.2
24 of 58, 769 yards, 3 TD, 4 INT
JAY CUTLER, Bears (10 games): 77.0
14 of 37, 425 yards, 2 TD, 2 INT
MATT RYAN, Falcons (17 games): 69.3
16 of 63, 518 yards, 4 TD, 2 INT

SPOILERZ AHLERHT:
Andy Reid no longer knows his dick from a stick. Readily apparent by watching his awesome coaching Sunday.

SPEELRZ UHLURT!!!:
Reid's shitty coaching on Sunday is irrelevant to his knowledge of QB play. You're being a real candy ass.

Yeah, he chose a man-crush on an aged game-manager. Tell me more of his "prowess"!

"Guru", my virginal ass.

As opposed to what? Seriously, give me an alternative. Geno(Akili) Smith?

Abso-****ing-lutely.

Oh, by the by, he's coming to Arrowhead. Prepare thine anus.

LOLOLOLOL. The dude is a Quincy Carter clone. I can't wait till the dicksucker is out of the league in 7 years so I can watch you zombies eat crow like it's pork steak.

no one earth would trade matt ryan for alex smith


jesus ****ing christ chiefs are the ****ing dumbest about QBs

Alex Smith quarterbacked a 2 win team to the playoffs. So far, so good John Dorsey.

Can't wait till Fissure and Smith are caught 69'ing each other in the locker room closet after a particularly brutal day of sucking cock on the field.


Cheers!

"Whistling through my teeth and watching midget porn, of course" / John Dorsey.

What are you going to say after he QB's a playoff team to a top 10 pick?

"What have you done for me lately?"

My oh my how optimistic this fan base has become.

BWA-HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

In what reasoning under God should a fan of this team be optimistic, you ****ing buffoon???

We SAID this was going to be same old shit when they traded for Smith, and I'll be damned if it isn't!

Lathah'....

Rinze...

REPEATAH!

A guy comes in, improves our win total by 9 ****ing games, puts up a 120 QB rating in the playoffs with 4 TD passes, and we have reeruns screaming that it's the "same old shit". I'm literally defenseless to this type of reasoning it's so absurd.

Can't defend it because its 100% true.

Matt Ryan is better than Alex Smith. LMAO

I have officially heard it all.

Yeah, that quick-fix was ****ING GREAT!

And today....


And being saddled with dick smack Axl...

And with Dorsey sucking cock at drafting...

And with a sweaty pair of Zubaz to wipe my BBQ sauce on...

And etc....

EDIT:

And with Reid sucking at game-day coaching!

SHALL WE GO ON?!?!?!?

THIS IS MY KIND OF PARTY! I CAN DO THIS ALL DAY*



*Singletarty reference.

succinct translation = http://media.giphy.com/media/UGygQcQhTyjmw/giphy.gif

Crying, again, would imply that I care or have an emotional investment in this bag of shit.

Reality?

On vacation until the next regime.

Then why are you so dogmatic over the issue? You sound like somebody who cares a lot.

I have a dream.

Say it with me; "WINKY-DINKY-DOG"!

exactly.. poor bastage cares.. This is simply his only way to express his miseries. Don't bash too hard... just take pity.

I wouldn't be so quick on Carson Palmer. He routinely throws for 4000 yards, but just has a bad knack of throwing INT's. He has an upside Alex doesn't, but also a downside Alex doesn't. I'd call that one a wash.

Yep.

Chiefs Planet has spoken!




And the consensus is...




Alex Smith ranks 12th in the NFL.





The results as of Sept. 10, 2014 are listed below. Since the top QB is at 91.9%, then Alex ranks at half that amount or 46.0%. Everybody scoring below 46.0% is considered by Chiefs Planet to be inferior to Alex Smith, hence his 12th place ranking.

Whodathunkit?





91.9% - - Aaron Rodgers
90.5% - - Tom Brady
89.0% - - Drew Brees
88.1% - - Peyton Manning
84.8% - - Andrew Luck
74.3% - - Phillip Rivers
70.0% - - Russell Wilson
65.7% - - Ben Roethlisberger

54.8% - - Matt Ryan
51.4% - - Cam Newton
49.5% - - Matthew Stafford
46.0% - - Alex Smith
45.2% - - Tony Romo
42.4% - - Joe Flacco
41.4% - - Eli Manning
41.0% - - Colin Kaepernick

37.1% - - Nick Foles
33.8% - - Jay Cutler
28.1% - - Robert Griffin III
23.3% - - Andy Dalton
11.9% - - Gino Smith
11.0% - - Carson Palmer
10.5% - - Ryan Tannehill
07.1% - - Derek Carr

06.2% - - EJ Manual
05.2% - - Jake Locker
04.3% - - Matt Cassel
04.8% - - Mike Glennon
03.8% - - Chad Henne
03.3% - - Shaun Hill
03.3% - - Ryan Fitzpatrick
02.4% - - Brian Hoyer

Damn, that looks pretty accurate. ^

Romo, Flacco, Manning, Kaepernick, Foles, Cutler, Dalton, Palmer, Tannehill > Smith

If you are in the 35% that didn't pick Ben then do not pass go and drink 1 cup of anti freeze.

Geno / clayanus

Look at this dumbass.

Wow. LMAO That requires a double helping of anti freeze.

LMAO what a massive list of bullshitters.

*threat has been detected!*... It really bothers me when I get those here, is there some kind of hacker asshole at work on the premises?

Seriously, wanna jack me up somehow? Meet me somewhere but leave my damn computer alone... ****ing coward.

Ok, JUST checked back into this thread and IMMEDIATELY got another threat warning... does the mod/owner team take this kinda thing seriously, honest question?

If I had to guess I believe I can guess pretty well who it is, you bitch coward.

What's a threat warning?

A virus/spyware warning... just now got another one as I typed.

Its no threat, this place will get on fine without me I'm sure... but if management doesnt look into this stuff then I'll just get lost, I dont have time for hackers, this place used to be well clear of that shit.

AustinChief, I ask you to look into this.

Stop looking at porn.

Attached.http://www.chiefsplanet.com/BB/data:...AAAElFTkSuQmCC

I got it too. I use Avast.

You could easily rail him for Palmer as well. I was never a fan but that dude is playing some legit ass football this season.

I'm not scared of the Steelers but we gon' get fisted in Arizona.

TOP 25 dumbasses on CP.... Nice list of the usual suspects...

505 Chief, BigCatDaddy, ChiefsCountry, cmh6476, Count Zarth, Crush, Dave Lane, DidierDrogba11, DrunkBassGuitar, Ebolapox, Fish, GoChargers, HemiEd, hometeam, Javabean, KC native, KCUnited, MoreLemonPledge, New World Order, Nickel D, Pawnmower, rico, Snapplez, stonedstooge, Titan43

They should be pinned at the top.

They were so sure Geno was going to come in to Arrowhead and prove everyone wrong...

Now the scrub might not even play, their day of reckoning went up in smoke.

Let the weeping and gnashing of teeth begin.

Please let Geno play against the Chiefs. The thread would be delicious.