So you're telling me that Herm is the GM now?

WTF?

Considering that Herm wanted a full-on rebuild to take place since 2006 and Peterson ignored the request and continued to sign over-the-hill and less than mediocre talent at every sore spot, I'd say that's accurate.

Dane, you can keep crying about a lack of talent all you want.

They have shown they have the talent to win how many games this year - at least 5 by my count - only to have wins taken from them by bad coaching decisions.

I said they had a floor of 4 wins and a ceiling of 6.

Based on the way they've played in the 2nd half of the season, it's more than fair to say i would have been dead on had there not been a bumbling idiot on the sidelines grasping defeat from the jaws of victory.

Oh geez Dane, give me a break, you know he had a say so in the personnel, stop reaching :rolleyes:

Really?

I guess you haven't been paying attention, nor have you read EVERY interview with Carl and Clark specifically stating that CARL and CARL alone was responsible for the signing of McIntosh AND the decision to stick with "the old guys".

Those were CARL PETERSON'S DECISIONS, not Herm's.

Only if he can stab himself in the back..... ****ing weasel...

I guess we'll agree to disagree.

In New York, he made the "mistake" of not going for it on 4th & 1. There was no guarantee that they would have made the first down, nor is there a guarantee that they would have scored. But I guess in your mind, that's an error on Herm's part. Running at Kris Jenkins with Kolby Smith? Who's going to win that battle 90% of the time?

Versus Tampa Bay, the defense fell apart without the services of DJ and Flowers. The Special Teams suck because there's no depth across the entire roster and they'll continue to suck until the roster is rebuilt.

In San Diego, are you blaming Herm? They went for the win. I guess you think he erred and they should have kicked the extra point (even though he already missed one PAT) and attempt to win in OT?

And last weekend, where did Herm err? Surtain gave up the TD. Bowe fumbled. The kicker missed a 16 yarder and a 50 yarder. Where did Herm err?

I guess we just see these games much differently.

:huh:

They both are teh suck and both need to be removed...

I read this kind of stuff everyday. Herms track record speaks for itself. The guy is a horrendous gameday coach and a pretty blah evaluator of talent, just some think he's great at it because of what was here before.

It's also widely reported that Carl's greatest fault is giving TOO MUCH control over personnel decisions to his coaches.

This was undoubtedly the case with Grandpa, but now you're claiming that Carl was ruling with an iron fist (Edit: with Herm, sorry). Not hardly.

Look, I believe that Herm was hired with the mandate to try to win with that decaying '06 squad. From '07 on, this thing has been Herm's baby, IMO. And it sucks. Again, for me it's all about what he's done (read: hasn't done) with the defense.

Carl has been quoted as saying he signed McIntosh and he alone thought they could "win with the old guys".

I'll be happy when Peterson delivers his final speech after the season's over so these issues can be cleared up once and for all.

Who keeps putting McIntosh out there on the field?

If he would of kept his man pleaser shut instead of acting like a pompus ass when he arrived, Mr God ****ing gidt to the Tampon 2 and will correct everything DV did wrong.. It wouldnt be so bad. But the ****ing loser ass douche nozzle, opened his cock holster and hasnt lived up the his self proclaimed hype of being a defensive guru....

Uh, don't you think that if there was someone better on the squad, they'd be out there?

For ****sakes, Johnston was out there before he was injured and he was a 7th rounder.

Peterson, as usual, did nothing to prepare for the departure of the "old" offensive lineman.

Has to be Carl....:thumb: