Charles was better than McCluster his first year yes. Charles has much more speed.

i have no idea how people can even compare charles and mccluster....


but i guess i'm too personally involved to see mccluster's playmaking-ness

Everyone is too pissed off at Pioli for not picking their favorite 2nd round player that they ignore everything positive about McCluster and amplify every negative.

Who has compared them?

Not me. Just asking clay why he bashes so hard on dex , it's personal, and gives jamaal a pass.
Posted via Mobile Device

charles "gets a pass" for the obvious reason that he's one of the best rbs in the league....he is/was our offense


mccluster is a position-less midget dubbed "playmaker" for whom some people would like to see start "making plays"...

What did you propose we do about Charles fumbling Jason? Bench him? Dude barely got any carries as it was.

What's your definition of making plays? Is it 60 yards on every catch/carry? I'm perfectly fine with his 6+ yard runs and the occasional 20+.

the same thing we do about dex, bitch. i guess.


but lets not sit here and act as though it wasnt an issue. it was and is, hell he fumbled TWICE in one game in the PS. fumbled at the WORST time against baltimore in the playoffs.

it was an issue.

dex has made plays. 5+ yards a carry

Dex needs an update.

14 touches:

5 receptions for 17 yards
9 rushes for 45 yards

5 receptions for 17 yards. :LOL:

Ya man. I'm not sure why his receiving yards are so low. He's always getting the ball 20+ yards down field.

Fourteen touches for 62 yards is pretty blah, especially when five of those are receptions.

Most running backs average 7-9 yards/reception.

Cmon GC

whats his ranking on PFF as a running back coming into this game?

There should be a countdown to him breaking. Dude is too small to be taking the punishment he's receiving.