Winnar

http://photo.oempromo.com/Prod_165/R...y_14749527.jpg

first off...Manningham wasn't wide open...#21 was going to destroy him if Smith threw him the ball

secondly, he wasn't throwing it to Manningham...it looks as if he was throwing it to Kyle Williams...who, for all we know, Smith expected to stop rather than run the same route 3 yards behind Manningham...

either way...that's just a normal incompletion

that is neither a bad play or a good play

just normal

it's pants-shitting excitement of the matt cassel variety, and nothing else.

[QUOTE=Go to Hell;9458223]Winnar

Hey does the ring still work while homey is standing on his head???


ROFL

Just a heads up CP:
the sooner you guys figure out the entire 49ers message board is viewing this board, the sooner you will stop throwing out uneducated 49er stats. You can't compete with 9er obsessed fans on 9er factiods.

And when I say the entire 9er message board is viewing this board, I am not exaggerating. There is currently a thread: "Come here to laugh at the Chiefs"

Ps, the majority would like to see Alex, and therefore the chiefs, succeed (unless you are playing SF).

SO throwing it 10 yards from an open receiver is normal???? ha WTF???? I guess your are right, a horrible incompletion is normal coming from SMITH...:LOL:

Tom Brady throws an incompletion like that probably about 5 times a game...just from the pocket because he doesn't often move from it

that's a 100% normal incompletion

you guys are ridiculous(ly) stupid

There won't be any good play gifs coming.

I once saw the legendary Tom Brady drop back to pass on his first offensive play in a Super Bowl...launch it 50 yards down the field to absolutely no one in particular...and take a safety.

What a terrible QB.

HE SHIT HIS PANTS MATT CASSEL STYLE! OMFG

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xB_x0nOMHKI

Link?

IF YOU DO NOT STATE EXPLICITLY THAT ALEX SMITH SUCKS THEN YOU ARE IMPLYING THAT HE DOES NOT

THEREFORE **** YOU

Wtf is up with the Barbie girl song?

IDK I watched it on mute

That's right, **** me! oh wait

you shouldn't feel too smart

you don't even know how to tip properly at restaurants

It's bullshit I can't read this.

Wahhhhh????

LMAO

you have internet access on your porch?

If you werent such a douche, id give you my user name and password and you could see it for yourself.

Lucky you.

OK, I registered and now I can read.

The message board is so highly populated that it runs too slow if they allow non members to view. Therefore,.... sign up and laugh at our dbags.

WELCOME ALEX!

http://i.imgur.com/MwBEnUp.jpg

go on

I'm probably going to ignore hootie. Some of the statements he makes are without sense.

I encourage this.

You have to be a member to read anything there. It used to be you could just lurk, but the servers were getting crashed on Sundays with all the traffic. Our Alex Smith thread would routinely go to 300 pages during the week. They just don't have the servers for all the people who want to lurk there. So they went to a system where you have to join to read the posts.

They've pre-banned you.

Pattern: 49ers fans settle for an underpowered message board and an underpowered QB.

It's time for Clark to step up and give us a QB worth of our message board.

They're having a huge discussion over my 2-27-1 stat. LMAO

Hahaha. Thank you 49ers fans.

Your posts in this thread are hilarious, considering how much you used to love him. :D

It's okay. It was just a year ago Milkman and Austin called him a franchise QB.

LMAO

I never loved Alex Smith. I liked him as a backup QB/replacement for Croyle. There is a huge difference between that and him being our starter.

Yep LOL

I'm not sure what you're getting at, Dave. I'd still take him as a backup here. He also had a good arm before he got hurt, and he's still mobile.

GOATSE

once again

it's another LOADED, DIPSHIT, STUPID ****ing stat that all occurred PRE-HARBAUGH

JFC man...

Since Harbaugh, he's 2-3 including a playoff win using that LOADED stat. You're just using "bust" Alex Smith against the guy he's actually been the last two years.

One of those 3 losses was the miracle "Tony Romo punctured lung game" as well.

Dude, you can twist any stat you want to make Alex Smith look like Matt Cassel because he was a full fledged bust for the first four years he was in the NFL...

but it's real fair to compare that situation to an Aaron Rodgers who got to take over a team who was a Favre **** up and a Crosby miss away from making the Super Bowl.

My ****ing God dude sometimes you are just totally pathetic.

"HIS CAREER STATS ARE MATT CASSEL'S!"

Do I need to keep crushing you with this all night/week/month long or...?

It's not stupid. To do it only twice in seven years is embarrassingly pathetic.

If the 49ers didn't have such a great defense the last two years he'd have even more losses.

it's ridiculous

his level of play this year was pretty much Trent Green-esque

that's his ceiling in KC

we all wanted a franchise QB...we got Alex Smith

that's a fair reason to be pissed/disappointed

but making things up to pretend we got Cassel version 2 is pathetic

LMAO

and if Peyton Manning wasn't so good he wouldn't be so good!

So what QB in this draft is a Franchise QB?

Alex Smith >>>>>>>>>>Cassel

Throwing the ball down the field less than Matt Cassel is Trent-Green esque?

Taking a shit ton of sacks is Trent-Green esque?

I have no idea but I know, speaking for the majority of this board, if we tried and missed it would have been pretty easily forgiven.

I'll ask you one further.

What player in this draft is a franchise player worth the #1 pick?

He's going to come here, and when our D has a bad game, we will lose.

None it's a bad year for the first pick.

Yes. Alex Smith operated Harbaugh's gameplan very well. Alex Smith could be Trent Green in KC. He could also be Trent Dilfer. His ability is somewhere between those two. He's an efficient game manager who has shown ability to make plays the past two years.

Does this excite me? No, not really. I'd rather have drafted Geno or Barkley and taken a shot but apparently Reid and Dorsey aren't believers in these QBs.

I don't think they are Scott Pioli stupid, though. Reid always drafted/realized the importance of QB's in Philly. Dorsey went from Favre to Rodgers...pretty sure he realizes what the winning blueprint in the NFL is...and I doubt those two are stupid enough to hitch their wagons to Alex Smith for 4+ years if he plays like Trent Dilfer.

and you're probably right

but you need to stop using the bust Smith years as ways to beef up this argument you're having with yourself on this board

it's pathetic

Explain how Alex Smith is going to be #2 in the league in passing yards. Because that's what Trent was in 2003.

Unfortunately for you, 49ers fans seem to agree with me.

Alex Smith will never be Trent Green, he needs to almost double his production :/

I personally never disagreed with you...

but he's 2-3 in that situation since Harbaugh came to town and that's the stat you should be using...

what Alex Smith did at the start of his career is absolutely irrelevant since he's now been a different guy for 24 straight games.

the only reason to use Nolan/Singletary Smith stats is to try and prove he's something he isn't...

Alex Smith is an efficient game manager. That's what he is. Does that win in the NFL on a consistent basis?

No.

throw the ball to Tony Gonzalez and Priest Holmes a lot

So you're on record then?

Alex Smith could have a 4,000+-yard season here?

I'd predict somewhere between the 3500 and 4000 range, yes. McNabb never really threw for over 4000 yards so I'm not going to be like "yeah, for sure."

But in a Dick Vermeil offense? Could I see Alex Smith throwing for 4000 yards? Yeah, absolutely.

No. 4000 or more. In the top 10 in passing. Preferably top 5, since that's what Trent was.

Alex Smith doesn't fit a Vermeil offense, either. You know this.

why the **** would Alex Smith not fit a Vermeil offense?

and no, I'm not betting that.

I don't even like the Smith move.

I'm just not a complete ****ing moron who needs to be a drama queen and start comparing him to Matt Cassel because he certainly isn't Matt Cassel.

Because the offense emphasizes throwing the ball down the field, dumbshit.

pretty sure Alex Smith has every bit of the arm Trent Green had

this is getting ridiculous

They didnt emphasize deep passing here.

You'll disagree immediately, but Smith has as strong, if not a stronger arm than Green.

Kennison and Morton ran 12 yard dig routes! THAT'S DOWNFIELD PASSING!

ALEX SMITH IS A CAREER 10% PASSER ON 12 YARD DIGS.

There were lots of intermediate throws in the offense in the 15-30 yard range.

Alex Smith almost literally throws 75 percent of his passes under 10 yards.

So go ahead and keep ****ing that chicken, hootie.

dude if that Eli thread wasn't locked I'd love to bump it right now

I AIM'd you before he won the Super Bowl that year...before they went on that run...and was like, "you know who has impressed me this year?! Eli Manning."

and then you chastised me and told me how terrible he was and how stupid I was

I don't think you know what you're watching.

Deceiving thread title considering Alex Smith is 20-6-1 and has played well in the playoffs.

Not really the definition of "suck".

Trent Green threw 188 passes in the 11-30 yard range in 2003.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/player/splits...03/trent-green

Alex Smith threw 102 passes in the 11-30 yard range in 2011.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/player/splits...011/alex-smith

Go ahead and tell me Alex can run that offense! Let's not even go over the fact that 49ers fans tell us Alex refuses to throw the ball into tight windows down the field.

Alex Smith under no circumstances will be as good as Trent Green here.

How many playoff games did Trent Green win in KC?

I seem to remember Alex Smith winning more in SF. LMAO

Trent Green would have won 6 Super Bowls if he had the #2 defense, dumbass.

Trent Green never threw into tight windows, either! LMAO

that was my biggest complaint the Huard/Green year...

my entire premise was...

"Huard is the shitty QB that forces the ball to Gonzalez and Bowe when they are covered and that is why he needs to play because Green won't do it and just takes constant sacks..."

literally

that was my argument for Huard...that he let our playmakers make plays and Green wouldn't throw into those windows because he was too smart/too used to the Vermeil offense where he always had an open guy

lololol

I keep hearing the words "would have" and "should have" instead of "playoff win" and it makes me laugh.

Trent wasn't that great of a QB. He was hidden behind the best OL I've ever seen and a strong running game.

I'm willing to see if Reid can surround Alex Smith with necessary tools to succeed here, because he's played well in the playoffs before and there's no reason to believe he can't again.

This is just hilarious. Alex Smith has 6 TD's to 0 INT's in his 2 playoff games and he sucks?

JFC people the guy only had 1 year with a decent OC before Harbaugh showed up.

Reid thinks he has even more potential. Let's wait and see.

He did it all the time you ****ing dumbass.

In fact he got into trouble over forcing the ball sometimes.

Don't make me post ****ing GIFs.

Alex Smith is a goddamn checkdown king and you think he can run Vermeil's offense. LOL at you.

Smith are Green are not the same QB. Green's passes in the 20 yard range are fast and flat compared to Smith's. Highlights don't tell everything, but clearly Green has more of downfield game than Smith. It's not clear at all that Smith could have ran the Saunders offense as well as Green.


<iframe width="420" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/gLlW8lIEwhc" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/G42tL7D509s" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

sure

post .gifs of the Green/Huard year...you're going to find a whole lot more Huard fitting the ball into windows than Trent Green.

Alex Smith basically never, ever makes throws like this. He wouldn't even attempt this.

http://uranus.ckt.net/~gochiefs/dante.gif

Herm Edwards first statement about the offense was that he wasn't comfortable with the risks Green took in the passing game. Not to mention Green really never came back from his decapatation. So ignore 2006. Go back to 2002 through 2005. Watch the highlights I posted. Green hit plenty of windows.

Alex Smith does this all the time!

http://uranus.ckt.net/~gochiefs/morton.gif