If you were rating QB's purely on their passing ability, i'd put Vick outside the top 15. But you aren't.

The ghost of Bobby Douglas salutes you sir. :)

If you include his running ability I would put slot him right next to or a spot above Roethlisberger.

Fair enough. I'm still not sold on Roethlisberger, but I agree with you with putting Vick in the top 10 QB's (which DOES include both passing/running).

Nice catch, TO. ROFL

TD Falcons.

Sweet. 14-0 Falcons.

Eat it, Iggles. 4321

Niether one of them I would call an upper tier QB. Not a guy who is going to lead your team through the playoffs.

Yeah, Atlanta got to the conference championship... of one of the weakest conferences ever after beating the worst playoff team in history.

8 or 9 is where I would puthim on the 'who would you rather have' scale.

The Eagles getting OWNED! MCNUB looking like hell and Owens had the look on the sideline like someone poked his old lady and kicked his dog, priceless!

eagles going for 5 nfc championship games...its not looking good

Who cares? The entire conference is a fucking joke.

At least one turd in the sewer is going to end up floating on the top.

Eagles driving though.

That was a nifty trap play.

Yep. Shit floats sometimes. :D

TD Eagles.