Last year

Vince Young 4 touchdowns 9 picks

Tyler Palko 2 touchdowns 7 picks

That one pick against PIT has to count for atleast 2, if not 2 and 1/2.

This is reeruned.

He led a clutch, end of the game drive to beat the Giants in his first start in a new system, and the Eagles were 2-7 at the time.

Everyones bitching about Cassels lack of passing yards and VY's best season came with 2500 passing yards and 17 INTs.

Vince Young is not ours. So naturally he's an elite QB we should not miss out on.

You obvious didn't watch Eagles games.

It's convenient you left out the game against Seattle towards the end of the year where he eliminated the Eagles when he threw a pick 6.

Also your claim that he's gotten better every year is an inaccurate one. He hasn't completed above 60% of his throws since 2008. He hasn't thrown for more than 12 touchdowns since 2006.

No he doesn't. He throws like the uncle from Napolean Dynamite.

Colt Brennan and Timmy Chang set college records for Hawaii, then busted in the pros. Neither was even as good as Cassel. College records are just college records and have no bearing on whether a QB will be good in the pros.

That's not completely correct.

QBs that start 2 seasons or more in college don't always succeed but QBs that start 1 season or less almost always fail.

Does that make sense?

Well, I would agree if you said that college records are not guarantees of success (actually, I already stated that in this thread) but I disagree pretty strongly with the idea that college records have no bearing.

Seriously, who would you rather have on this team right now- Cassel or Mallet?

It's a shame, really.

Cassel has problems with vision and decision-making. A quarterback has to make his reads, make a decision, and get the ball to the best possible receiver in a matter of a few seconds. Cassel simply cannot do that with any consistency. You can have all the other physical attributes and an awesome attitude, but if you can't make quick reads, decisions, and throws, you cannot be successful.

Cassel's brain is wired for baseball ... not football.

FAX

No bearing = no guarantees of success. Two different ways of saying the same thing.

Colt Brennan started 3 seasons. He sucks more than Matt Cassel that didn't start at all. Colt Brennan broke a bunch of NCAA passing records. He sucks worse than Matt freaking Cassel. My point that breaking college records doesn't mean you will be a successful pro QB stands, and can't really be denied.

Given the issues described in Daboll's resume, it's possible they didn't exactly develop him properly.

FAX

You didn't even read what I said.