Ryan was speaking after a very tough practice for the rookie quarterback, who threw four interceptions -- three in 11-on-11 drills to the third team defense and one in 7-on-7 drills.

“It was brutal. It was Geno’s worst day."

http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/jet...-a-possibility

How many interceptions has Alex Smith thrown in TC?

.

In what way, shape or form does that have ANY bearing on Geno Smith's 4 interception practice?

Maybe 6-7 all TC practices combined

That is the first day Geno Smith thrown any INTs so I was just wondering how many Alex Smith has had @ camp so far for comparison. This is a thread Geno vs Alex is it not?

It's training camp, if I were a jets fan and I had a horse in the race I wouldn't really care until he does it in a game.

Se as I don't really care about fishers tc reports until they start popping up in games

Sounds like Geno Smith had a bad day at camp.

At least it's not his 3rd year in the league I guess.

Newton threw two interceptions, and nearly a third Tuesday in his worst practice of training camp

Read more here: http://www.charlotteobserver.com/201...#storylink=cpy

I actually expect Mark Sanchez be week one starter, but after a few games they turn it over to Geno Smith. I bet they dump Mark Sanchez for next season and Geno is their starting QB. Mark Sanchez is going be on a short leash as the NY crowd is not going put up with him very much. Rex will be forced to make the switch one way or the other or it's his job.

Yeah, Cam's unproven. The media should be all over him.

You're ****ing dumb.

Geno Smith had an awful day at practice throwing 4 interceptions. His head coach said he was awful and your response is "How many has Alex thrown?".

They are NOT in competition with each other, nor do they play on the same team. The only competition between Alex Smith and Geno Smith lies within your feeble mind.

This thread is about Geno Smith vs Alex Smith so I just wanted make a comment that Alex Smith has thrown plenty of INTs and this is the first day Geno Smith has thrown any.

Apparently Geno Smith had a real shitty day no argument from me about that.


Lighten up Francis.

Rookie QB's aren't supposed to have a shitty practice. Once they are a vet than it's expected they have a shitty practice apparently.

Will Geno ever get to the "assclown of preseason" stage of his career?

http://assets.sbnation.com/assets/3047661/camclown.gif

Enjoy it now you yuppies. I can't wait for this moment.

http://i164.photobucket.com/albums/u...ps631263bb.gif

And I will be reusing this later in the season.

:facepalm:

Yuppies? What the ****?

Yeah, call when the multiple bad days start piling up.:shake:

Adam Schefter ‏@AdamSchefter 1m

Jets HC Rex Ryan on QB Geno Smith's day: "It was brutal; that was Geno’s worst day."

Douche>>>Cam

Adam Schefter ‏@AdamSchefter 30s
More Rex Ryan on Geno Smith: "We’ve seen it, guys have bad days, but this was a really bad day for Geno."

Adam Schefter ‏@AdamSchefter 1m

More Rex Ryan on Geno Smith: "We’ve seen it, guys have bad days, but this was a really bad day for Geno."

Q

:D

They were speculating that the ankle was the culprit that he couldn't drive the ball.

Which is why I said from the beginning that the Jets was the worst team for him to go to. His competitive nature let him get back on the field, and he has a good probability of re-injuring that ankle and setting himself back further.

He is going to be a good player, but he has to listen to his body.

He looked fat in last week's preseason game. He looked fat and sloppy. Rolling your ankle the way he did on a routine play is embarrassing and shows how out of shape he is.

He looked slimmer in college and at the combine.

No, no, no. He, like Sanchez, must be a starter from day one! God forbid he be taken at 1.1 over an ALL IMPORTANT Tackle, and put behind a clipboard in a small market like KC with a decent coaching staff!

But hey; we've got Chase Daniel!

VIVA LA AWESOME!

If here were here, with no Alex Smith, with the talent that is on the Chiefs, he could start here day one.......

There is no talent around him in New York. The right side of their offensive line is atrocious, they have no idea when Holmes is going to be back, their tight end is some dude named Cumberland, and Stephen Hill, is awful. They also have some Receiver named KERLEY.....that's his weapons.....

Pretty much everyone, myself included, knew the minute he went to NYJ, he was in for an uphill battle at the very least.

That would have happened wherever he went.

He is NOT NFL ready.

BFD if he struggles his first or even in his second year. It's his third year that is going make or break him as an NFL starting quarterback.

Eli Manning threw 4 INTs against the Vikings his first or second year iirc? He went on to win two Super Bowls. It's if they can over come adversity and become a consistent winner.

4 INTs in a practice is hardly something to be concerned about.

In fact, when Geno takes over the starting role this year, I expect him to have a few bad games. Par for the course for a rookie QB.

Dane's overreactions then and now are priceless.

strictly football speaking. Arent you the guy who blew out of proportion a throw away in preseason? While I agree with you that its not a big deal, your acceptance for certain people and not others, is hilarious.

Why would a 9 year vet get the benefit of doubt and a rookie QB doesn't?

0 irony in this post. To what are you referring?

Early warning signs should not be ignored in the case of Alex Smith. He's a 7-year NFL veteran. I expect him to make throws like the one I pointed out.

Geno Smith is a rookie. He gets a lot more leeway. A lot more.

Oh shut the **** up. As if every single poster here can't see right through your bullshit.

You're no doubt referring to my propensity to hold Alex Smith's flesh to the fire over every little mistake.

I understand. This annoys you, because I'm more lenient with the object of affection, Geno Smith.

While on the surface this may appear to be a double standard, it's not. Geno Smith is a rookie. More leeway is given to him as he develops into a future NFL star.

Alex Smith is a veteran, whom we gave up two valuable draft picks for. The balance of the careers of our most loved stars are in his tiny hands. He is held to a much higher standard, and rightfully so.

So Alex Smith will be held to the absolute most stringent standards of all time, where you will verbally rape him for not hiding the ball well enough on ****ing play actions, etc, but Geno Smith could throw 7 TDs and 30 INTs and and it'll just be a rookie season gone awry on a team with not enough talent surrounding him.

I'm glad you're stating this now, since we all know Alex is probably going to have at least an average season. Meanwhile Geno, if he plays, is to going to be an absolute train derailment.

Geno will be evaluated fairly. 7/30 would be cause for concern. I would like to see him do something akin to Sam Bradford's rookie season, in an ideal world.

Alex Smith needs to on ****ing point. No excuse for anything else.

Well, that's a fair point. I guess you have me there. Smith is a veteran and Geno is a rookie. You win.

Wait a second...


BASED OFF ONE PLAY IN TRAINING CAMP WHERE TYSON JACKSON BEAT HIM.

Insta-reactions to training camp tweets should not be taken seriously, son.

I thought Eric Fisher played well in his first preseason game.

Fair enough. I understand your point about Geno being a rookie. Bad things will happen this year for him whether he's ultimately successful in the future or not. But, I don't want to see any bullshit about "Oh Alex didn't do this well enough or blah blah blah" when Alex Smith has an obvious good game. And that definitely includes when he has a good game, we move the ball, score a lot of points, but still lose 35-30 or some shit. I don't want to hear the old "Well he lost the game" shit. Be reasonable is all I'm saying.

.

Ah... so it is up to the reader to decide when you should be taken seriously?

Good. Because my read on it is about 0.0001% of the time.

If we lose the game because Alex fails to make a play when a play should have been made, he will be blamed.

In 2010, when we lost to the Texans (35-31 IIRC) because Cassel shat his pants in the clutch, he rightfully deserved blame.

I guess I shouldn't take your insta-reaction (There's nothing to be concerned about) to Geno's 4 INTs in camp seriously. Perhaps you were just kidding and you're really pooping your pants over there, wondering "Gee I wonder if this Geno guy is gonna flame out ****in early?"

BTW, I'm just ****in with you. I don't give a flying **** about Alex OR Geno. They can both die of aids tomorrow and I'll sip my coffee and take a dump.

We don't have a Jets training camp thread where insta-reactions flow like milk and honey, so my Geno reaction should be taken seriously.

Bad day for Geno, but he probably learned something from it. I'm positive he will take this poor day of practice and improve on it.

Sorry but my chubby for Geno just went completely limp when he was drafted by the Jets. That's almost as bad as getting drafted by Oakland (but not quite). Sometimes you can just tell what's gonna happen based on the teams. Oh, and there's also the opinion I have molded over time, and that is that Geno Smith is kind of a ****ing idiot.

Geno sucks. Always has always will.

I cant wait for the excuses to flow in about out how the Jets are a horrible franchise to play for and hes been "ruined".

Start your backtracking now Geno nutgobblers

I think the Jets are a quality franchise. They've been to the AFC Championship in recent years. That's hardly Raidersesque.

Totally. I 100% agree.

And there's nothing wrong with looking at past results as a predictor for future success. But it isn't ironclad. It isn't definitive.

The problem is that you like to make really bold, really declarative statements that will either A) come true and you look smart, or B) be wrong and are buried amid 35,000 other things you post a day.

Either way, it creates discussion and argument and gives the forum an antagonist which is useful during offseason lulls.

But it's just frustrating at times and becomes exhausting. Especially when you know damn well that Alex Smith is a massive upgrade from Cassel. He's not elite. He might even just be barely average. But Cassel was absolutely, without question, one of the worst starting quarterbacks we've ever seen.

I'd rather have Damon Freaking Huard than Cassel. That's right. I'd rather have an idiot with a noodle for an arm and a vagina for a face.

So, rail against the chiefs for not taking a QB. Rail against them for giving up too much. Rail against the retread SF quarterback. God knows I have. But keep it legitimate and within the realm of reason.

We'll see.

<iframe width="420" height="315" src="//www.youtube.com/embed/B2L1-TgfKb4" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

Eh, Raiders were in the SB a decade ago. Christ it doesn't seem that long ago. **** I'm old now.

Anyway, I just meant Oaklandesque in regards to QB suckage in recent years.

I don't think it's bold to think Alex Smith is a waste of our time, probably won't be taking us anywhere this season, and that Geno will be a good NFL QB.

ROFLROFLROFL

Define "a good NFL QB" Clay.

Does he have to be top 10? If so no he will never be that.

Top 15?

At least average.

I think he could be like Jay Cutler.

His face isn't nearly punchable enough to be in the Jay Cutler tier of QBs. What Cutler's face is to my fist is equivalent to what my couch is to my ass. Just right.

Eli is a feast or famine guy, like Brett Favre. It is either TDs or INTs -- nothing in between.

Good God, NO...

Well that's fair, but having a full blown melt down on two forums because Alex Smith had an incompletion in a preseason game. That's a bit much.

I hope he learns that if you are genuinely hurt, don't push it, it only makes things worse.

Geno with 4 ints today!
LMAO

I wasn't melting down. You have no idea what a GoChiefs meltdown looks like.

Funny, people here say its no big deal he goes seven or more practices without an int.


Then all these guys make a big deal of him doing what most qbs in their rookie year do.


He has probably still thrown less than most guys in camps
Posted via Mobile Device

I agree asshole :D

Q

Go to your Bray thread and post that nonsense.

You're jealous.

Don't you sort of hate the corner you've painted yourself in? What I mean is, you'll still be happy if players like Alex or Dexter do something positive, but it will be a little bittersweet due to all the arguments and shit here. I get that its not that big a deal, but there is still gonna be a little piece of you that says "Ha!" If Alex throws a pick or has a Casselesque game. And likewise if he does well a tiny piece of you will say "****!"

Not particularly. I know that none of these wastoids are ever winning us a Super Bowl, so **** them all. In the mean time, poking fun at them amidst a legion of crying homers is a good time.

I think he's tired, like we're all tired, of the 40+ year drought. Alex Smith wouldn't be so bad, but it's just that we went just went through what feels like this before, with Matt Cassel. We gave up a steep payment in draft picks, and we get a very middle of the road Qb, which closes the door on us to draft and develop our own Qb for at least a few more seasons.

No way Alex Smith gets benched, unless he is absolutely dreadful, like Matt Cassel in years 3 & 4. But I think GoChiefs, like we all think that Alex Smith is not that bad, and that he will do just enough to keep his job and keep us in mediocrity.

When Alex Smith is done, we will be 3 years further away from our last championship, and we will be right back in the position we were 4 years ago, and the position we are in now. Now, we could luck the **** out with one of our backups and they turn into a Brady (a savior) but this is wishful thinking.

I (I don't know about GoChiefs) really want this Alex Smith thing to work, but gut instinct just doesn't foresee him winning a championship for us. Which is kind of they point of why the suit up, and is a jading reality...

What you're giving up on the Super Bowl already? The season hasn't even started yet man!









Yeah we aren't winning the Super Bowl.

It's that gut feeling pulling at you. It's that feeling of dread just like with the Royals, where you know unless they win the ****ing lottery of luck, they will not win a championship unless there are changes in the way the team is run and changes in the economic of baseball.

Yep.

It's like I've got a restraining bolt on my homer switch.

I get all of that and agree to an extent. On the other side, I don't know who else we could have acquired that would give us a better chance to win this year and next year with the nucleus of talent already present. I'm not a homer fool, but I think the possibility of Alex turning a corner with a new team and new coach is there. But like you said, lots of fans here are jaded with good reason and don't think that will happen. But hell, I'm gonna hang on to that hope and give Reid a shot with the guy he obviously thinks he can accomplish great things with.