Nunez-Roches' hit on Shaw Dirty?
 

I've seen some discussion around the interwebs suggesting the hit that broke Shaw's leg was dirty. They didn't show a replay on TV. The only video I could find is here: http://www.arrowheadpride.com/2016/8...-broke-his-leg


Thoughts?

Not any dirtier than Talibs late hit last night. Why isn't that being talked about?

Not a dirty hit at all. He was just pulling him down.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Unecessary? Yea. Dirty? I don't see intent.

Shaw got pulled down awkwardly and nothing more, PERIOD

Probably unintentional but very reckless.

Reverse the teams and tell us what your opinion is.

I bet most Bears fans wish it happened to diabetes boy.

I'd really like to see the play in real time instead of slow mo. Definitely a weird body position for a tackle but I don't see it as being intentional. It's hard to say why his legs ended up where they did.

Dirty as shit.

To me a "dirty" play requires intent (Ben Davidson spears Lenny late) or profound stupidity (e.g. Suh and Haynesworth stomps).

Nunez-Roches was just trying to finish a play and while it may have not been necessary it's tough to hold-up when you're already so committed. It looks bad because the ball was gone, but how many times have you seen a QB pull down a ball at that point? There's no evidence he was trying to hurt the guy, despite what Shaw said on Twitter after the fact.

I don't think so. Shaw just happened to end up with his leg in a freak position and pop.

So were the Bears as they kept jumping on players who were already stopped/grounded - **** that dude - Initially I felt bad for the kid - but after reading he'd indicated that it was cheap - Stay down bitch!

So a dozen posts in here, all saying that they don't think it's dirty and why. Then you jump in with "dirty as shit" with no explanation as to why you think it was dirty. Such credibility. We all respect your opinion when you are so e;eloquent in your response. SMH

stupid or whatever maybe

but like others have said it seemed accidental and just a freakish thing

i bet he feels like shit