NFL MVP?
 

Who wins it.

Peyton "Waterhead" Manning

He was nothing special this year.

I want Favre to get it. I like the old man.

**** Favre. He could die and I wouldn't give two shits.

:spock:

Rivers

Do I need to prove it?

Manning and it won't and shouldn't be close.

Chris Johnson deserves some love

Other than the 14 wins and the 33 touchdown passes and the 4500 yards he was worthless.

The media votes on this, right?

Then it'll either be Favre, Manning, or Brady. (Yeah, Brady. We're talking about the media here.)

Manning will win it....Favre or Johnson should win it. I ****ING HATE the colts and Manning. A1 Ghey1!!

This was not one of his better seasons. What about those 16 INTs?

What about those come from behind wins? What was it.....something like 7 in a row?

Manning 4 sho

He was not better than Drew Brees. Yet nobody is talking about him.

I don't know if it's one of his better seasons, but it's certainly one of everyone else's better seasons.

For those arguing for Favre, he's arguably not even the MVP of his team.

Take Favre off the Vikings and where are they? Still in the playoffs like last year.

Take Peyton off the Colts and where are they? Drafting a handful of spots later than the Chiefs this year.

Thats true. But for Peyton he was not the same player as he has been in the past. He does not prove worthy of getting that award over Favre, Brees, or even Aaron Rodgers.

So who is then? It's not Peterson. Jared Allen? I don't think so.

Both Peterson and Allen could be considered the MVP of the Vikings.

That doesn't ****ing matter. Just because you're stats go down from the previous years doesn't mean that you don't deserve the MVP.

Brett Favre is not the Vikings.
Peyton Manning IS the Colts.

I would almost put a bet on Sidney Rice.

LMAO not even close! I mean, maybe, maybe Allen. But Peterson puked all over himself this season. He fumbled when it mattered most, and had a difficult time breaking 100 rushing yards after his week 1 game vs Cleveland.

I'd narrow that list down to Manning and Brees. My choice would be Manning, but I couldn't argue if it were Brees.

That wouldn't have anything to do with Captain Audible......:rolleyes:

And who made Sidney Rice? Brett Favre did. Rice would not be in the pro bowl this season if it wasn't for Favre. This is a terrible arguement. Go ask Rice himself and he would tell you the exact same thing.

He only audibled about 15 times the entire season...:rolleyes:

:shake:

Rice has already stated in an interview that if not for Favre his career would not be soaring.

Which is what's bound to happen when you go from Travaris Jackson to an above average QB.

I wonder who Halfcan will vote for?

Peyton Manning
Brett Favre
Drew Brees
Chris Johnson

In that order.

With Chris Johnson as the NFL Offensive Player of the Year. They didn't start winning until Vince Young started playing.

It's not like Jackson is a bad QB. Did you not notice how well he played during his last few starts?

Matt Cassel FTW

I have trouble voting for someone that road the bench the last 2 to 3 games.

Brett threw for 4 TD's and over 300 yards his last game-from 1st game to last he played nearly every snap. He had the biggest impact on his team, and his best year ever.

mangina had 16 INTS and should have lost a few games if not the D for the Colts.

Breeze kinda sucked at the end of the year.

Rivers might just be the dark horse-hard to argue with his year.

And here we have the totally made up BS stat. Are you seriously suggesting the Favre audibled less than one time per game? Laughable

ROFL

Bam. Halfcan FTW!

Brett of course-he had a HUGE year-only 7 picks, over 4000 yards.

Chris Johnson had MONSTER year-I think he gets it.

Brett
Chris johnson
Schaub
rivers

Yes. And can you prove me other-wise?

Most valuable player to his team = Peyton Manning, easy call.

he picked Matt Schaub over Peyton Manning?

Hilarious.

Manning or Rivers....

Farve then Brees

I am not the one here citing the made up stat. How about you cite your source good sir. There is NO WAY for you or anyone to know how many times he audibled this year.

you can't pick Chris Johnson with a straight face...only reason they started winning was because of Vince Young...he made Chris Johnson THAT much more potent when the ends had to start respecting Vince Young's legs as well.

Rivers didn't even make the ballot? Damn.

Rivers led the league in Yards per Attempt, 1st Down %, and 20+ Yard Passes.

He didn't have nearly as many attempts as all the other candidates, otherwise I think he would have won it this year.

He was 18th in Attempts.

Schaub 1st
Manning 2nd
Brady 3rd
Rodgers 6th
Favre 8th
Brees 10th

I think drew had it wrapped up til the last 3 games-All losses. Brett came from behind by playing well. The last 6 quarters of play 6 TD's over 500 yards.

last 6 for mangina Zip

last 6 for breeze Zip

Rivers sat the last game too so that might have hurt his chances-but SD had a hell of a year-they man handled people. Hate to say it-but I might have been wrong about Rivers-he had a fantastic year.

Yep not sure why he is not getting talked about-but damm he played good. :clap:

Manning or Rivers.

Christ, the Vikings made the playoffs with Tarvaris Jackson at QB last year. Missing Favre means they don't get a bye week.

The Colts missing Manning means they likely don't make the playoffs, and I don't see the Chargers making the playoffs without Rivers, either.

But damm look at the numbers-record breaking season.

That's why the award is stupid to begin with.

MVP is always going to be a QB, because they play the most important position on the field.

This is what, the 6th time a RB has broken 2000 yards, and he'll probably finish 4th in the voting.

But he sat the last two games and threw 3 Ints in 2 seperate games. 16 picks this year!! some of them lame ducks just floating away.

I dont think mangina deserves it.

Favre stated in an interview in week 15 that he has only audibled 10 times the entire season. I am saying 15 audibles were made over the entire season. I watched the Vikes this entire season. When it looks like he's audibling he is just pointing out pass protections, whos the blitzing corner, and directing receivers on how far to bend their routes. He did not change an entire play more than 15 times this season. Besides this... Favre has been in the NFL for nearly 20 years. If he feels that he needs to audible, it is probably the correct call.

I agree-johnson had statistically the best year of a RB ever-all purpose yards that is. But the titans missing the playoffs will probably hurt his chances too.

Unless a RB scores 28+ TDs in a season, then they win the MVP, see 2005 - 2006.

that is why he can have fun with his offensive player of the year award...

if the Titans finished 14-2 or at least made the playoffs MAYBE he would have an argument...

Farve would have won it if he hadn't blown the entire month of December (1-3 record, 4 TD, 4 (of his 7 total) INT).

Brees' numbers are comparable to Favre's (actually better than), but they of course collapsed late in the year, as well. And he's nowhere near as high profile.

Indy's last two games don't help Manning, either, obviously, but he probably gets it.

But the media LOVES Favre, so it wouldn't shock me.

Chris Johnson isn't getting it, not on an 8-8 team, 2k yards or no 2k yards.

Ditto for Schaub on a 9-7 squad.

exactly ;)

He had a hell of a year though.

Here is another stat for you.

the previous 3 seasons before Favre

Vikings -2006 - 282 PPG

2007- 379 PPG

2008 - 379 PPG

2009 w/Favre - 470 PPG

That is a huge impact.

Mangina had the 7th most INT's in the NFL- that is not an MVP stat-sorry.

Favre would have won the MVP had it not been for his minor rough patch in December...

That's why I have him at #2 and Manning at #1...

I forgot about Rivers...

Manning
Favre
Rivers
Brees
Johnson

Stats don't always paint the whole picture buddy...

Manning had a great year. MVP worthy, no doubt.

Not to mention the come from behind wins and the leadership that he brought. 107 QB rating-2nd best in the NFL. He was not dink and dunking either.

I don't get it. What about Manning's rough patch with his INT's the entire season.

Tell me, who is the only QB in the NFL over 2009 that had OVER 30 TD's and LESS than 10 INT's???

the thing is its NFL MVP not colts, vikings, chargers, etc. NFL. IMO this year its farve.
Posted via Mobile Device

Rodgers had a good year too...but his play was somewhat shaky until they shored up that offensive line.

That throw VS the 49ers is MVP worthy in its own.

rough patch-?? two games he was just okay-but he finished very strong. 6 T D's in 6 quarters. He actually had a better year this year than his other MVp years.

the Vikings have Adrian Peterson...

The Colts ARE Peyton Manning...he won so many games in the 4th quarter this year...he was super super clutch.

Peyton Manning will win the MVP...so it's just not me with that opinion.

The award is not which player is most important to the LEAGUE, it's who's most important to their TEAM.

Manning or Rivers.

heck of a throw-but the catch is one of the best ever

Yup and you can't argue with that. He made Shaincoe into one of the best TE's in the NFC also.

If Rogers didn't get sacked so damn much I might say him. Lets say he got sacked 20 times less, that would have probably amounted to 2-3 more wins.

Hilarious.

Favre is #2...great year...but since that team has Jared Allen and Adrian Peterson...two super super super IMPACT players...it would have taken 14-2 and not losing to the Cardinals/Panthers and Bears the way they did at the end of the season for me to put him above Manning.

When they were 11-1 I had him as my MVP and almost even put a bet on him winning MVP when the futures odds were 2:1...

manning had what 4 come from behind and Brett 3? 4 if peterson does not fumble it away against the Bears.

Well don't be surpised if it ends up being Peyton and Favre.

Did you not watch the Vikings this year? Peterson almost never ever had an impact this season. I love AP, but he had a bad year for himself and was benched a few times throughout the season to Chester Taylor.

But there were at least two games both Losses that manning did not help his team at all. Not his fault I know but-he only played 14 games and had 16 picks in those games.