I tore my ACL.
 

5 years ago.

I collapsed on a soccer field, definite pain in my knee. I struggled walking and limped for two weeks. I couldn't afford an MRI at the time.

Two weeks later. Pain had gone away, I could walk without a difficulty.

A year goes by. I can run, but can't play sports.

Two years go by, I can play sports.

Three years. I play sports, work out, run half marathons, Tough Mudders, etc. Without a knee brace.

Finally went in to see a sports doctor today. He told me I tore my ACL 5 years ago, and that I've been doing all of this activity on a torn ACL. Holy shit.

Says he just recommends an MRI and a few weeks of therapy to test it out. At that point, I've already built muscle back up and I'm perfectly functional, so no surgery seems needed.

Has anybody else done this? I can't help but think this is absurdly unusual...

Lucky you, I guess! I hope there are no complications but at this point, it seems unlikely if you can do all that stuff with no pain or problems.

The physician himself said it was highly unusual.

I'm basically Wolverine, right?

Na, once you reach a certain age and there is no real reason for you to get it fixed, you'll get the option of just living with it, especially if it isn't bothering you.

The doc is just going to suggest you keep your quad, calf, and hamstring strong because those are your reinforcement areas and as long as you keep those in shape it shouldn't give you much trouble outside of a few aches sometimes whenever a cold front comes through.

i'm sure your Obamacare will cover your pre-existing condition now. :D

No, you didn't magically repair your ACL. It is still torn. You have just built up the supporting muscles to a point that you can function without it. Good luck as you get older and keeping these muscles strong enough to support the joint becomes harder and harder.

This all true.

I tore my ACL when I was 22. I waited 2 years, then had knee reconstruction surgery. It turned out my ACL and PCL were both completely shredded. If you don't need the surgery, that's awesome, because the surgery and subsequent recovery is far more painful than the original injury.

Ray Farmer needs to see you in his office.

If you could walk on it two weeks after, it's a small or partial tear. Your not putting weight on it if its torn completely; there's basically no stability in your knee. Once the inflammation passed he was ok. I completely tore my ACL, partial MCL and some damage to medial meniscus and had to be helped off. I tried to put weight on it.. no way.

No point in getting surgery to fix a partial tear. Even if your semi-competitive in sports, might as well wait for it to tear complete. It wont unless there is a traumatic event to the area.

Had the ACL surgery for my right knee in 1989. They still opened your knee up wide to do that surgery. I have two big scars on that knee but it feels great and no problems with it.
A few years later I tore the ACL in my left knee playing football. I didn't know how bad till I turned 40 and had a MRI for knee pain after a summer of volleyball. Turns out I had Broken leg and a torn meniscus, plus the ACL. I decided to have it fixed and they did all that surgery with a scope in my knee.
Went from two huge scars to four tiny holes....Amazing..

America! Where religion is a right, and health care is a privilege!

My wife did this. She tore it probably 20 years ago playing softball. Never had anything done then and a couple of years ago she was having pain in her knee and went for an MRI. The doc told her the ACL was gone. She had the reconstructive surgery and 3 months later hiked to the top of Angel's Landing at Zion NP. See pics below.

She's one tough cookie.

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedi...4013732%29.jpg

http://www.panamintcity.com/zion/image/ang2.jpg

Fire Dorsey

I did it when I was 36. Along with torn meniscus. Had it repaired but did not do much PT. The doctor said since I was not an athlete or I physically tough job, that I could do simple exercise and be ok.

I was walking 2 days after surgery. He required it. Had a few pains with the weather but mostly ok now.

Just get it done. You are still young enough to need full mobility and little pain.

How bad is the tear? I'd recommend a second opinion too.

i tore mine years ago and have never done anything about it.

It happened to my cousin. Only a few years later he had to have surgery as he didn't heal right. You lucked out.

I use a Health Rider. Very low impact, targets more than one muscle group at a time.

Anal cavity lips?

Honestly the doctor has no idea how bad you tore your ACL until they do an MRI. When I originally tore my ACL the first doctor told me that I was fine but when I continued to have problems I went to another one and they finally ordered an MRI. He probably did stability testing on both your knees and found one was weaker than the other. If your not doing many cuts in your physical activity than you can function very well without an ACL. The surgery and rehab is extremely painful. Way way worse than the injury. Usually you will here a pop in your knee and it swells up right away. I was able to put weight on it a little while after and limp walk. Ended up I blew my ACL and tore up my meniscus. Basically ended my sports career. I recovered but was never the same player physically that I use to be. However, surgery and rehab is leaps and bounds better than it was 10-20 years ago.

You are incorrect, sir, although I understand why you think that.

I completely tore my ACL and my PCL. I had to be carried off the softball field, and it hurt like a mother****er. A few days later I could walk on it, but my knee was very unstable. I couldn't jog or run on it. It would occasionally bend the wrong way when I was just walking on it, and when that happened it would hurt like hell and swell up for about 4 days.

Based upon his description, I agree that Direckshun's ACL is probably partially torn. But I am living proof that you can walk on a completely torn ACL. I just learned to walk carefully and never make a sharp turn while walking. (By the way, it sucks to have to live like that.)

Before my surgery, my doctor thought my ACL was partially torn for the reasons you stated. He had to open up my knee to figure out it was completely torn, and the 90 minute surgery turned into a 4 1/2 hour surgery. My doctor knows a little about ACLs, as he was the team physician for the Chiefs for a couple of decades (Dr. Jon Browne). He had done thousands of ACLs before he did mine.

Dejuan Blair says you're a pussy and your mom is a whore.

http://www.slate.com/articles/news_a...o_problem.html

My heart sunk when I read the thread title on the front page.

I've got a friend that had a similar incident. It had already been repaired surgically once. The second time he said **** it. He's been rocking and rolling for 6-7 years now.

Everything depends largely on whether or not you have lost your burst.

And this comment has what to do with this discussion? You've turned into a real douche lately.

I had a friend who did a similar thing. Lived with it for about 3 years. He complained of a little pain whenever we played basketball. He got drunk and played haki sack one night and ended up injuring it even worse.

I've noticed that too.

are you going to be ready for the playoffs?

ROFL