Chiefs Offseason Planet Evaluation: Charcandrick West
 

Give me your best on Charcandrick West.

Poll coming faster than an unchucked Tyreek Hill.

Just for the record, no one was Inb4poll.

I'm not quite convinced that Sherman couldn't fill West's role better. And with Hunt's emergence, I suspect that Ware may end up being a better version of West as well.

I think West will be an endangered species in training camp next year, because I think Ware will end up taking his role. I've got nothing against West and he seems to be a popular fellow on the team, but if I'm putting a small guy in on passing downs, I expect him to make more impressive plays.

TrashCanDick....


Solid C average

I expected him to be cut prior to the start of this season, but because of Wares injury that didnt happen.

I dont think he makes the squad this coming year.

I gave him a D.

I cant help but think about how phenomenally he played when JC got hurt a few years back. WTF happened to that Charcandrick. He is gone. So he gets a D, because I know what he is capable of, but he doesnt live up to it.

Prove me wrong 35.

Pibb brings back so many great childhood memories.

He's nobody. Any RB can do what he does

He pass protects better than most so there's value in that.

He sucks!

He's fine as a #3 RB behind hunt and ware

I think he's a #2-3RB, 3rd down back. He's better in pass pro than Ware and Hunt and for those reasons I gave him a B-. If we choose to use Sherman like a FB should be used, then he's probably expendable.

2.04 Grade (4.0 point scale)
-0.36 Performance Relative to Expectations (+ = Positive Surprise, - = Negative Surprise)
-1.23 Desired Future Role (+ is larger role, - is smaller role)
-0.31 Ascending/Descending (+ is ascending, - is descending)
6.32 Trade Value (Round)

I'm a little surprised that people on average see Charcandrick as descending. The rest doesn't really surprise me.

Plain old C, if not for his pass blocking its a D-

Seems like a great guy, too bad he is so very replaceable

Meh

He's fine. Does his job. Good in pass pro situations. Pretty decent receiving back. Decent speed for a pure rb which is a good change of pace.

Tell me more about these Supermodels....

I'll take Akeem over Char W every time. :thumb:

Kareem and Spencer have good power for their sizes with KHunt having better hands with the ability to take it to the house whereas Ware does not.

Akeem is the quickest out of all the RBs with what my football eyes have seen with decent power as well and good hands.

Sherman is very deceptive in that he can catch well out of the backfield and you always need a FB regardless of the rest of the league moving away from this. Sherm is a great option to have in the offense because of his versatility and back door surprise plays when needed.

West needs to be cut.

RB's are easy to replace relative to other skill positions and the Chiefs have done well over their history to do so. I don't mind West, especially as a 3, but I would like to see them take a late flyer on a different 3rd down back that has more explosion. West does block well though, as mentioned.