Chiefs Planet: Closest to 32 Challenge (2021)
 

Stealing this idea from Reddit in an attempt to add some first round intrigue Thursday for us Chiefs fans.

Here are the rules:

1. Select the least number of players on the Google Form so that you are confident that you have EVERY player who will be actually selected in the first-round on your list. According to the Reddit thread I stole this from, last years winner needed to select 54 names while the closest runner ups were between 55-70. Moral of the story here is don’t be too tight with your picks because inevitably the Raiders will f**k everyone over by drafting a “Damon Arnette” pick. If you don’t get all eventual 32 players selected, you’ve lost.
   
2. Among those who get all 32 first rounders correctly on their list, the person with the fewest total names on their list wins. Example: someone who only needed 54 names to identify all first rounders beats someone who needed 65 names.
   
3. Tiebreaker (if needed) will be the extending the format into the second round to find the first unique selection. Example: Both players lists included the names of picks #33 they are still tied, but only player B had the name of the #34 selection, then player B wins the game.

Reward = bragging rights

>>> Chiefs Planet Closest to 32 Link Here <<<

I stole the names from the Reddit game to make things simple on me. The Reddit OP claims they are the top 150 names from a consensus board, it doesn’t specify which. There is an “other” option if you feel someone is missing.

Please only submit 1 entry. Entries will be accepted up until the start of the draft. I will share results Friday or Saturday.

Edit: It appears that there are two ways to interpret the rules in OP. See my post from today (4/28) below. I like both ideas! I will identify winners for each group. If you want to play both ways, feel free to make two submissions.

For data junkies and curious minds: link to last years’s Reddit results

Nice try trying to get my email

You don’t want in on the latest and greatest pyramid schemes? Or photos of the worlds 50 cutest pets?

Is it requiring an email? I disabled that when setting up the form. Only thing I see is your response to “What is your CP user name” and the list of players you select. Is Google requiring a sign-in to participate? It didn’t for me, but I also leave my Gmail signed in on my tablet so perhaps it bypassed that step...

Submitted

Haha I was just messing

In

In

Got mine in earlier

We are up to 12 entries! Will leave submissions turned on for another 24 hours.

Interestingly enough, it appears that the rules were confusing (no personal offense taken, I largely copied and pasted from Reddit as said in the OP). We are split close to 50/50 between two different groups.

Group 1: Picked 40-80+ players in an attempt to guarantee that every single first round pick is on your list by using the fewest names possible - if you miss 1 you lose (intention of the OP as stolen from Reddit)

Group 2: Picked 32 players with the intention of trying to accurately guess as many 1st round picks as possible

Both interpretations are fun! I can analyze and post winners for each group. If you submitted for one group/interpretation and would also like to submit for the other, feel free to do a second entry. I will assume that any submission with only 32 names marked is for Group B.

Lol I landed in the middle. I picked like 34 or 35 i think. So basically, a really shitty Group 1 entry.

I did 32 because that’s how many players will go in the first round.

Kind of self explanatory.

Won't be shitty if you correctly nailed all the first round picks! You'll be the winner by a wide margin.

I probably went too conservative, I think I had close to 75 names on my submission.

I went back and did a second submission with just the 32 names - some I'm entered for both games.

Bump: we are up to 15 entries. I'll shut it down around the start of the draft. Hoping to share results late tonight... But it may slip to tomorrow.

Don't leave us hanging

I thought this was a fun and interesting exercise... we should do it again next year with a more clear OP. I will try to follow up later with additional assessment of the most commonly “missed” picks for both groups.

Group 1 Results (submitted 32+ names)

Winner: Kellerfox

I was able to correctly identify all 32 first round picks, but had to put 68 names on my list to do so. Per the rules stolen from Reddit, as the only person with all names correctly identified, I am the winner despite the large list.

Runner Up: Kccrow

Crow got 31 of 32 picks on his list - the only player he missed was DE Payton Turner. Crow’s list only included 48 names, so had Turner been on it, he would have been the winner by a healthy margin (using 20 less names than I did).

Others:
#3 ChiefNJ2 - got 28 picks correct with only 36 names on his list
#4 The Franchise - got 28 picks correct with 39 names on his list
#4 Apollo12 - got 28 picks correct with 39 names on his list
#6 Voyager - got 27 picks correct with 37 names on his list
#7 Lurker - got 24 picks correct with 38 names on his list


Group 2 Results (only submitted 32 names)

Winners: 4-way tie between TambaBerry, Wilson8, Voyager#2, and Kellerfox#2

These 4 correctly identified 26 of the 32 first round picks. Voyager and Kellerfox made 2 submissions, one for each interpretation of the rules.

Runner Ups:
#5 Dante84 - 25/32
#5 AJKCFAN - 25/32
#7 Lurker - 24/32
#8 Inmen58 - 22/32
#9 YontsRBake - 21/32

Alright, between the two groups we had 16 total responses. The table below identifies how many times each first round draft pick was included on one of our lists. The most commonly missed players are highlighted.

Most common misses as a group were:

1. DE, Payton Turner - Saints
2. CB, Eric Stokes - Packers
3. OT, Alex Leatherwood - Raiders
4. DE, Joe Tryon - Bucs
5. RB, Travis Etiene - Jaguars
6. LB, Jamin Davis - WFT

https://i.ibb.co/fxxYnHS/DC3-A440-A-...6-E65190-F.jpg

Thanks for doing this. There were a few tough ones that surprised me.

Yeah very fun thank you for bringing this