![]() |
Bills/ Bengals [cancelled - process in OP]
In case anyone needs it spelled out, we would play at a neutral site if the AFCCG ends up being Chiefs vs. Bills. All other scenarios abide by the usual rules (so any other game the Chiefs play will be at home).
Old posts:
Spoiler!
|
Will be interesting to see how they handle this. Adding another week to the season sounds like something that would be a logistics nightmare for the entire league. Not to mention fans that already have flights and hotels booked will be screwed. Of course, no matter what they do, some will be unhappy.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
But not only this, the other 30 Teams don't deserve punishment because neither team wanted to continue the game. (Regardless if its right or wrong) |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I think the best solution that will be the least impactful to all NFL teams, including the Bengals and Bills, is to resume the game tomorrow and then reschedule their week 18 games for Monday night.
|
As far as I am concerned both teams decided last night to forfeit the game.
|
This is a shit sandwich for everyone involved, Bengals, Bills, and the NFL.
I think the best thing to do is just not play the game. Then do the seeding by winning %. Chiefs would have the #1 seed, but still need to win. Buffalo and Bengals still have a shot at the #1 seed. |
Quote:
That would be a league wide nightmare. If anything, it seems like let the Bills/Bengals play this weekend, then push the 4 teams affected to that following week. Let the other 28 teams play this weekend. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Yeah, that seems like a solid and persuasive argument. |
Quote:
They flew back to Buffalo, didn't they? I see no logistical way to play today. |
Quote:
|
There is no easy answer, there will be plenty of critics, and life goes on.
It is the way it is. |
Quote:
We had a player off himself in front of our COACH and GM and we played two days later, as scheduled. "Nearly Died" We have seen players become PERMANENTLY PARALYZED and they continued to play. The unfair advantage is some teams would be RESTING players next week. Now this throws a wrench into the entire seeding issue. |
Ravens can win the division
Chiefs can get one seed The implications of this single game to the entire playoff seedings are kinda huge. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
We now know that he didn't die on the field. But at the time, none of those players had any idea if he'd make it to the hospital or even off the field alive. Not the same as a guy being taken away by an ambulance on a stretcher with fear of a potential paralyzing injury. |
Quote:
simplest thing would be 1 of two option. 1. Resume the game tomorrow. 2. Bills take the loss. The first one makes the team play on a short week and calls into question the very thing this whole deal is about, players safety. That is a bad look imo. If it was a the Chiefs in this situation I would rather go into the PO as a 2 seed then play 2 games in 4 days and then another short week into the playoffs potentially. Risking further injury and especially after the team is shell shocked. Just forfeit the game move on. I think you can also look at it like an OT game in reverse where the arguments are both teams should touch the ball etc. Well, the game has to end at some point as unfair as it is that Mahomes didn't get to touch the ball in the 18 AFCCG. I know that the situation is completely different but freak injury (assuming the cardiac arrest was from injury) made the game be canceled and you just take the final score. |
I would think they play tonight or tomorrow night. I know there's no MNF games the last week of the season, but Bills/Patriots and Bengals/Ravens games could be played Monday night.
There's really no way to be completely fair to the Bills or Bengals, or to the fans and stadium staff that will have to rearrange things. |
Forfeiting the game for both teams is only thing that makes sense
|
Easy solution is to play the game tomorrow and move their week 18 games from Sunday to Monday. Then you make sure if they have to play on wildcard weekend that their games are on Sunday and not Saturday. This gives both teams one day extra rest as compared to a normal Thursday night game for their games on Monday and still gives them the same amount of rest as any of the teams that have to play on Saturday the first week of the playoffs.
This has the least amount of disruption to the rest of the league and still treats the Bengals and Bills with as much fairness as possible. |
Quote:
Tough decision but I think they need to play it tomorrow or the Bills take the L. |
Quote:
It is a freak occurrence everyone has to understand that and as such it needs to be mitigated as much as possible, that being keep it between the two teams. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Damned if you do, damned if you dont. We didnt today-and parents are mad. But it is not snowing, it may snow later. Cant win or make everyone happy. |
To me playing tomorrow, and their next games next Monday, seems quite logical.
I 1000000% support not playing yesterday, but what is the argument against tomorrow? Obviously we all hope for Hamlin's recovery, but none of the players or coaches can change that. He'll have his family and a ton of other support there. I'm just not sure what good it does the team sitting at home. And it seems like after the initial shock wears off, of course it's still a tragedy, but life has to go on... especially if we get the best news possible that he's recovering. |
Quote:
|
pft
Quote:
|
Quote:
Otherwise, just eliminate the bye week before the Super Bowl and move everything back a week. People should grant that the NFL is in an impossible situation here, and there is no solution that is going to make everyone happy or be completely fair to everyone. |
Quote:
I think a part of it is they are wanting to see what happens with him because if you play Wednesday and he passes away or is deemed status up in the air or something during or before the game then what? It could take awhile for test before they know his situation and especially if you are going to try and play tomorrow. All the logistics involved in that. That is why I think playing may not even happen and I am not sure that it should. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Anyway, there's the open question of when the game will be rescheduled..." :doh!: |
Just schedule it for tomorrow and make the other games Monday. By tomorrow (and any time today really) they will likely know the long term prognosis of the player so the uncertainty and mystery will be gone.
|
Quote:
|
If the game (understandably) can’t be played today or tomorrow, then the only option that makes sense to me is to cancel it and not award a victory to either. Win percentage determines seeding, followed by head to head.
It isn’t fair to the Bengals and Bills, but I don’t see an option that would be fair to them and the rest of the league. I know it sounds callous, but it’s probably best to keep the unfair things limited to as few of teams as possible. |
Quote:
For the life of me I can't see the NFL not playing, or only having one game on weekend where there were going to have two stand alone Saturday games and a full slate on Sunday. I really thing the best case is to simply not play the game and simply move on to next week. It gives the Bengals and Bills time to move on. It doesn't disrupt the rest of the season or the playoffs. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
The problem is that it will appear to be rather cruel to the Bills. They fall out of first place, lose a player, and still have to play a tough divisional game next week. The Bengals lock up the division under this scenario correct, so maybe the Ravens are butt hurt, but hey there team is a mess anyway. |
Quote:
It sounds cold and all, but that’s the only way. |
Quote:
Not to be insensitive or anything. But aren't these guys football players? Don't they portray themselves as gladiators and warriors? Know what a gladiator and warrior does when the guy next to them goes down? Keeps going. This isn't even the first time this has happened on the field of play. Some how Hank Gathers dying on the court and what happened after is somehow forgotten. There is no time to reschedule. Extending the whole league a week is a nonstarter. Bills should either accept they need get back on the field by tomorrow or accept the forfeit. |
Apparently the Bills already flew back to Buffalo. I'm guessing it won't be resumed tonight.
They need to figure out a way to complete this game soon. What happened is really unfortunate, but if the exact same thing had happened to him a few days before the game, would anyone be talking about cancelling the game permanently? I highly doubt it. |
America is so weak.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
But this game just isn’t fair sometimes. Seasons get wrecked in week 1 when franchise QBs go down with season ending injuries. Careers get ruined due to freak accidents. It’s not ****ing fair, but every team faces the same or similar risk every week. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
They could just play week 18 out as normal and only resume the Bengals Bills game if needed the following week (pushing back the playoffs). If this happens, its highly likely the game is a dead rubber for Bengals and they will just sit all their starters.
|
Quote:
I get last night was traumatic, hell I wasn't in the mood to watch football let alone play it afterwards but its time to man up and stop playing victim. This is life, it was an unfortunate accident and the guy is still alive. |
Quote:
1000% this. if they cant / dont want to play it, then they should just concede the L and move on. |
Quote:
I understand your point, but that's the whole thing. There's no solution that doesn't effect more than just these 2 teams. That's why I'm quite certain they'll play it. The logistics aren't even that hard. It's just handling the PR and making it a fair and reasonable situation for the players to have to play. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
All the people buying tickets and trying to plan for playoff games not knowing where or when it is to be played? Besides the game outcome IS needed in any scenario. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
100% |
Quote:
There is no "fair" at this point. That ship already sailed. It just is what it is and the 2 teams involved, mainly Buffalo will have to to take the hit if it comes down to it. We have heard 1,000 times since last night its just a game, ok then well just take the L. Injuries affect the outcome of games all the time. |
Quote:
if only the mods could show some strength and ban your ass, you god damn bundle of logs |
Quote:
It's PR and their genuine or feigned concern for "making" the 2 teams play after an "appropriate" amount of time. |
Quote:
I think that is not accounting for the Bills players and what they will think about that. They may have a mutiny about it. You also make two teams play on a short week after a freak injury. You take that situation out of it if you just don't play it and let everyone reset for Ssunday. If you just treat it like the bills lost a key player and lost the game because of it then it is easier. |
Quote:
If they can't play by Thursday night, and be willing to play by the following Monday then they should absolutely take an L |
Quote:
They were down when it happened. Sucks but everything else just makes it more complicated. |
They shouldn’t adjust the playoffs. Play the makeup game tomorrow, week 18 on Monday. Give them the Sunday slots for the wildcard round.
We don’t need to get too carried away here. |
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">(Ignoring games canceled by player strikes.)</p>— Quirky Research (@QuirkyResearch) <a href="https://twitter.com/QuirkyResearch/status/1610297041350967297?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">January 3, 2023</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script>
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
C'mon roger, hurry up.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
they wont |
All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:35 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.