Watching Geno Smith, I see a kid that has great feel for the game.

He doesn't throw lasers with every pass the way most strong armed college QBs do, but he has thrown lasers into tight windows when he has to.

His arm strength is underrated because he doesn't put it on display with most of his throws.

I don't think anyone actually compared it directly to Rodgers, I was just defending your inaccurate analogy.

Don't like his 52.7 completion % (I think he is capable of way more than that).

I think Saturday will tell a lot about Geno. I want to see how he responds against another good defense.

:facepalm:

take that stupid shit to the chiefscoalition.

Actually I did compare it directly to Rodgers.

I said he has comparable arm strength.

That doesn't mean he has the same exact strength, but it is strong enough to draw the comparison.

He was a bit off and had more than a few complete overthrows, but there wasn't a single phase that was working for WV against Texas Tech.

He needs to start stepping up and taking the yardage the defense gives him. Obviously no one wants him to be a scrambler, but he had many opportunities to step up and run for a first down.

Like you said...people underestimate his arm strength unless they watch an entire game.

Nevermind that he's been a starting QB at the college level for two years prior to this one.

Nope. This is the ONLY year when games against good defenses count. :rolleyes:

Milk is correct.

And makes a very good observation: Geno has superb feel for the game and understands and applies the correct velocity to his passes for the situation.

The guy has made numerous 50 yard in the air throws this season to receivers right in stride. Smith does have a very, very good arm (I'd say superb arm because he applies the necessary speed on the ball damn near every time).

It's his understanding and application at the position that makes him so desirable in my eyes as an NFL level QB. His feel for the game is uncanny. He's a natural at the position.

What a beatdown

I agree, but who has he played?

Right now I like Tyler Wilson the most. The kid showed a ton of potential last year against the best defenses. He even looked pretty good against the LSU, Bama and South Carolina defenses.

I know he looks awful now, but his coach is flat out terrible and his WR's are all in the NFL now.

I would love to have Geno on this team though. I think he has the ability to be a great QB. I really want to see him rebound this week though (I want him to throw at least 3 TD's in a loss because I want K-State to go to the ship).

And I don't get the Russell Wilson hate? Wilson was ****ing awesome his last year in college and completed 73% of his passes with 33 TD's to 14 INT's. He also has completed 63% of his passes with below average WR's in the NFL and beat Tom Brady last week, so forgive me if I don't hate him like some of you guys seem to.

Sadly, this will be the first time we disagree on a subject.

I think Rodgers has the most live arm in the NFL. > Cutler, Stafford, Vick, RGIII, etc. I don't think anybody is close, IMO.

TBS, I think that Geno has above average arm-strength due to his mechanics and footwork, similar to Tom Brady. Their releases are directly correlated to their arm-strength, IMO.

I'm probably wrong, but that is just what I see.

He beat NE's defense. Tom was not playing D.

I don't hate Russel Wilson.

I think that kid has huge upside, and will be a QB to be reckoned with in the years to come.

Doesn't have anything to do with hating Russel Wilson, this board is and was full of people that wanted Russel Wilson. Your comparison is what everyone hated.