Cherry picking.

LMAO

Favre, Brunell, and Hasselbeck all were coached by Reid in Green Bay. If you include them, his record with qbs is pretty damn good. If you're just talking Philly than I'd tend to agree with you

I don't think you can really just make McNabb an exception when he played 80% of Reid's tenure in Philly. That's kind of dumb. That'd be like saying Patriots QBs in the 21st century have been mediocre other than Tom Brady.

McNabb was the #2 overall pick, so you absolutely CAN make him an exception.

The Tom Brady example is PERFECT.

Hasselbeck blossomed in SEATTLE under Mike Holmgren, who just happened to be the coach in Green Bay at the time all 3 of those guys were there.

It's just as plausible that those 3 guys were Holmgren, not Reid.

Of course. Because the only OBJECTIVE measure of Reid's "guru status" doesn't give anyone a warm fuzzy.

Mostly due to McNabb being out every other year and Vick being a turnover machine last year...

Minus Vick. If you take OUT last year's "turnover machine", Reid's QBs have more INTs than TDs.

And included in that sample is Jeff Garcia, who had a LEGITIMATELY good season starting for the Eagles.

Goes to show that you can be a wizard, but when you're working with AJ Feeley, Kevin Kolb, and Nick Foles, the magic gets lost easily

I've said it over and over, I think Andy Reid is a GREAT coach. I legitimately believe that.

But I don't believe he's got the Midas touch with QBs. He's been great with talented QBs, first round guys like McNabb and Vick. Without the high draft picks, he's been mediocre to poor.