FF Question: Should I allow this trade?
 

The Numbers are close, but the names aren't... Just doesn't seem right for some reason...

http://i3.tinypic.com/25z5uth.jpg

White meat's recievers must really suck for him to consider this.

He's got Chris Chambers, Terry Glenn, and Lelie as his current receivers...

They are big boys. As long as it doesn't look outrageous and it is not the last week of the trade deadline, I see no problem with this trade.

I would vote agianst it, either up the ante for the guy to get peyton or just block it...

It is the beginning of the season. Why vote against it. If someone is making a mistake, let them make it. I would only have a problem with this trade at the trade deadline if the one giving up Manning is completely tanked and the one getting Manning is in the top 2.

This isn't a totally outrageous trade. Do i think the guy giving up manning is messing up? sure. But its not totally ridiculous. You shouldn't protect an owner from his own stupidity if isn't isn't purposefully trying to mess up the league

Exactly

Who's his back-up QB? If I had a stud back-up I would do this to upgrade the WR and TE positions.

Drew Bledsoe

Hmm, maybe he's thinking Drew will put up some huge numbers with TO and Manning will lose some without a running game. *shrugs* Either way I can see how he's desperate if he has to go into the season rolling with Lelie. Of course thats his own fault for drafting so crappy.

It's not a trade I'd make, but I'd only kill a trade if I thought there was collusion.

What am I missing here?