Quarterbackery: Round 9, Heat 4
 

No one west of the Mississippi in this heat.

Jacksonville

Mark Brunell - 8 seasons (scales up to 19 years of 50)
David Garrard - 5 (scales up to 12 years)
Bryon Leftwich - 3 (scales up to 7 years)
Blake Bortles - 2 (and current starter) (scales up to 5 years)
Chad Henne - 2 (scales up to 5 years)
Blaine Gabbert - 1 (Scales up to 2 years)

The Jaguars produced 4 pro bowlers, led by Mark Brunell with 3. Their record would scale up to 10 in a 50-year period.

Tennessee

Warren Moon - 10 seasons
Dan Pastorini - 9
Steve McNair - 8
Vince Young - 3
Pete Beathard - 3
Kerry Collins - 2
Chris Chandler - 2
Ken Stabler - 2
Marcus Mariota - 1 (and current starter)
Zach Mettenberger - 1
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 1
Jake Locker - 1
Matt Hasselbeck - 1
Billy Volek - 1
Billy Joe Tolliver - 1
Oliver Luck - 1
Gifford Nielsen - 1
Charley Johnson - 1
George Blanda - 1 (led the team for 7 seasons, but only 1 since 1966 and he was also a slimy cheating Raider)

The Titans/Oilers produced 13 pro bowls, led by Warren Moon with 6.

Washington

Joe Theisman - 8 seasons
Billy Kilmer - 7
Mark Rypien - 5
Sonny Jurgenson - 5 (led team for 7 seasons, but only 5 since 1966)
Jason Campbell - 3
Patrick Ramsey - 3
Gus Frerotte - 3
Kirk Cousins - 2 (and current starter)
Robert Griffin - 2
Mark Brunell - 2
Brad Johnson - 2
Jay Schroeder - 2
Rex Grossman - 1
Donovan McNabb - 1
Tony Banks - 1
Trent Green - 1
Heath Shuler - 1
Doug Williams - 1

The Redskins produced 12 pro bowlers, led by Sonny Jurgensen with 3.

Buffalo

Joe Ferguson - 12
Jim Kelly - 11
Ryan Fitzpatrick - 4
Drew Bledsoe - 3
Dennis Shaw - 3
Jack Kemp - 3 (led team for 6 seasons, 3 before 1966)
Doug Flutie - 2
Trent Edwards - 2
Tyrod Taylor - 1 (Current starter)
Kyle Orton - 1
E.J. Manuel - 1
J.P. Losman - 1
Kelly Holcomb - 1
Alex Van Pelt - 1
Rob Johnson - 1
Todd Collins - 1
Vince Ferragamo - 1
Dan Darragh - 1

The Bills produced 10 pro bowlers in 50 years, with Jim Kelly leading at 5.

Tennessee up, Washington down.

TEN/JACK.

How does 19 years of Mark Brunell (scaled) not beat Tennessee?</br></br>On a side not: 4 teams that Vinny Testaverde didn't play for at some point in time. Wow!

Super Bowl

I think I'd take 18 years of Warren Moon and Steve McNair over 19 years of Mark Brunell. And I like Brunell.

The next question is 19 years scaled of Garrard and Leftwich versus 9 years of Pastorini, 1 year of Mariota, and 9 years of various mediocrity like Stabler, Vince Young, Chandler, Kerry Collins. I'd call that kind of a draw.

I think Washington is the weakest QB situation in this heat.

I would take 1 Super Bowl victory over any of them...JMO

I don't really remember Warren Moon before the Chiefs and from what I remember wasn't very impressive so maybe there's a timeline bias. On top of that the Titans are kind of like the New York Jets to me. I wouldn't notice if they fell off the map so there's a bias.</br></br>I went Jags top and Titans bottom.

Mark Rypien appreciates your vote.

He was a killer in Houston. One might argue that the system helped him a lot, but nonetheless he was one of the top QBs in the league during that time.

I still sadly remember his 500+ yards against the Chiefs when he finally left the game out of mercy. That was a horrific game to watch.

He's a winner! :)