[warrior]

Originally Posted by mattschiefs

First post here to me I don't think this is the year to really judge Geno vs Alex.

Alex Smith is in his first year in a new system. While he is a vet and he should be held to a higher standard then Geno it still takes time for most qbs to get used to a new system. I give you Trent Green. His first year in KC wasn't anything to write home about. He would go on to lead one of the best offenses that KC has ever seen.

Geno Smith is a rookie. While I didn't think we should have drafted him at the time and still don't there's no telling what he will be yet. He wasn't right for this team. Rookies for the most part at QB with some exceptions are turnover machines. Geno has been. That's what the Chiefs had last year at QB. To go from turnover machine to turnover machine just wouldn't make sense with a team that had talent and could compete now. But Geno could still turn out to be a very good QB in the NFL. I myself think he will be a good not great starter. But that remains to be seen

Good post and welcome