Tim Brown is an injustice, Raider or not he should be #1 by a mile.
Bettis absolutely deserves to be in, 5th all time rushing leader...ever.
Strahan should be a given.
Brooks should be a given.
Left with a Shields/Harrison debate IMO.
I'd have a hard time with Haley or Greene personally. I think Haley was a probowl type player but not HOF worthy who happened to jump between the two most dominant teams to get five rings. I consider him a Hali level player. Greene put up impressive numbers but didn't seem to really dominate or stand out even in his era that much, more of just a gut feel of "meh" about Greene to be honest.
|