Yeah I think that's more perplexing than Aeneas Williams. He was a pretty good CB... I'm not sure if he's HOF worthy but he got kind of got lost in Arizona for most of his career. I'm sure there are fans in other cities who would treat Shields the same way.
But I probably would've voted Marvin Harrison in over Reed. I know he played with Manning, but still. Harrison had a great rookie year playing with Jim Harbaugh. He was a great, great WR. Awesome hands, the best route runner you'll see.
|