So... I finished my own personal QB rankings. I have them split into rankings as mobile QBs and pocket QBs. I have detailed write-ups of each of them on the link. And... well.. let's just say it doesn't go along with the consensus. lol. Not that my opinions ever really have since I started spending way too much time doing this stuff. *Please note that "mobile" does not mean "running." It has to do with a QB's ability to move and to throw on the run, incorporate rollouts, etc.
Mobile QB Rankings
Rank Name School Position Height Weight Round
1 Johnny Manziel Texas A&M QB 6'0" 210 1
2 Teddy Bridgewater Louisville QB 6'2" 205 1
3 Derek Carr Fresno State QB 6'2" 215 1
4 Blake Bortles UCF QB 6'3" 230 2
5 Stephen Morris Miami (Fla.) QB 6'2" 208 3
6 Aaron Murray Georgia QB 6'1" 201 3
7 Connor Shaw South Carolina QB 6'0" 209 4
8 Tajh Boyd Clemson QB 6'1" 222 5
9 David Fales San Jose State QB 6'2" 220 5
10 Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois QB 6'2" 219 6
11 Brett Smith Wyoming QB 6'2" 206 6
12 A.J. McCarron Alabama QB 6'3" 214 6
13 Brock Jensen North Dakota State QB 6'2" 226 7
14 Logan Thomas Virginia Tech QB 6'6" 250 UDFA
15 Zach Mettenberger LSU QB 6'5" 235 UDFA
16 Bryn Renner North Carolina QB 6'2" 225 UDFA
17 Tom Savage Pittsburgh QB 6'4" 230 UDFA
18 Jeff Mathews Cornell QB 6'4" 225 UDFA
Pocket QB Rankings
Rank Name School Position Height Weight Round
1 Derek Carr Fresno State QB 6'2" 215 1
2 Johnny Manziel Texas A&M QB 6'0" 210 1
3 Teddy Bridgewater Louisville QB 6'2" 205 2
4 Aaron Murray Georgia QB 6'1" 201 3
5 Stephen Morris Miami (Fla.) QB 6'2" 208 4
6 Connor Shaw South Carolina QB 6'0" 209 4
7 Zach Mettenberger LSU QB 6'5" 235 4
8 Logan Thomas Virginia Tech QB 6'6" 250 4
9 Blake Bortles UCF QB 6'3" 230 4
10 David Fales San Jose State QB 6'2" 220 5
11 Jimmy Garoppolo Eastern Illinois QB 6'2" 219 5
12 Tajh Boyd Clemson QB 6'1" 222 6
13 Tom Savage Pittsburgh QB 6'4" 230 6
14 A.J. McCarron Alabama QB 6'3" 214 6
15 Brock Jensen North Dakota State QB 6'2" 226 7
16 Bryn Renner North Carolina QB 6'2" 225 UDFA
17 Brett Smith Wyoming QB 6'2" 206 UDFA
18 Jeff Mathews Cornell QB 6'4" 225 UDFA
All JMO of course.