Quote:
Originally Posted by ThaVirus
Define "better". There are so many factors to consider. It's tough to definitively say one guy is "better" than another.
Assuming all things were equal and I just need to win one game, I'd take these guys over Alex:
Brady
Romo
Foles
Brees
Ryan
Newton
Rivers
Peyton Manning
Wilson
Kaepernick
Dalton
Roethlisberger
Flacco
Rodgers
Cutler
|
Alex Smith is currently #3 in Win% over the past three NFL seasons. I think he's as good as anybody if you want to win just one game. Numbers back that up.
Quote:
QBs I'd be happier that we just signed to a 4 year deal worth $68 million:
Brady
Tannehill
G. Smith
Romo
Foles
RGIII
Luck
Brees
Newton
Ryan
Rivers
Peyton Manning
Rivers
Wilson
Kaepernick
Dalton
Flacco
Roethlisberger
Rodgers
Cutler
Stafford
|
Brees is 35. Manning is 38. Brady is 37. Rivers is a petulant crybaby who can't carry a team. Cutler, Stafford and Romo are just as likely to throw you out of a game than win it for you and have a total of two career playoff wins between them. Kaepernick and Wilson were downright horrible in passing the ball last season.
Newton and Luck are the only two guys I'd take over Smith right here, right now in terms of giving a QB a big money, four year deal.