ChiefsPlanet - View Single Post

CoMoChief · 09-04-2014, 02:20 AM

Who's better?

Peyton Manning
Phyllis Rivers
Tom Brady
Ben Roethlisberger
Andrew Luck
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Matt Ryan
Cam Newton

I'd probably put Alex Smith somewhere between 10-15. There are 8 others listed below and I think Alex Smith would make it somewhere in the next 5 spots if there was a ranking. I can't put an actual number on it. It's just after the "elite" franchise guys, there are a bunch of middle of the pack guys that can fall anywhere between 10-20 depending on who you ask. Ask 10 people and you'll get 10 different answers etc. (and I know some people will complain about Eli Manning not being elite. Sorry, I just never thought he was an elite QB because he's just played so many shitty games and when I think elite I think of his brother. Even Eli has more rings, he's never had a Peyton Manning level type of game, at least none that I can remember, and if he has they've been rare).

(In no particular order)

Alex Smith

Joe Flacco
Andy Dalton
Colin Kaepernick
Russell Wilson
Jay Cutler
Matt Stafford
Eli Manning
Tony Romo

Teams that are desperate, delusional, too early to tell, or are ridin' the rookie train to a high '15 draft pick:

Oakland
Buffalo
Miami
NY Jets
Tennessee
Houston
Jacksonville
Cleveland
St Louis
Arizona
Philly (though I guess Foles "could' belong in the above tier, but I'll be honest he's in this group because I haven't seen much of him, and he hasn't been a starter for long).
Washington
Minnesota
Tampa Bay

09-04-2014, 02:20 AM	#301
CoMoChief Mahomes Dynasty Join Date: Mar 2005 Location: Parts Unknown Casino cash: $7662254	Who's better? Peyton Manning Phyllis Rivers Tom Brady Ben Roethlisberger Andrew Luck Drew Brees Aaron Rodgers Matt Ryan Cam Newton I'd probably put Alex Smith somewhere between 10-15. There are 8 others listed below and I think Alex Smith would make it somewhere in the next 5 spots if there was a ranking. I can't put an actual number on it. It's just after the "elite" franchise guys, there are a bunch of middle of the pack guys that can fall anywhere between 10-20 depending on who you ask. Ask 10 people and you'll get 10 different answers etc. (and I know some people will complain about Eli Manning not being elite. Sorry, I just never thought he was an elite QB because he's just played so many shitty games and when I think elite I think of his brother. Even Eli has more rings, he's never had a Peyton Manning level type of game, at least none that I can remember, and if he has they've been rare). (In no particular order) Alex Smith Joe Flacco Andy Dalton Colin Kaepernick Russell Wilson Jay Cutler Matt Stafford Eli Manning Tony Romo Teams that are desperate, delusional, too early to tell, or are ridin' the rookie train to a high '15 draft pick: Oakland Buffalo Miami NY Jets Tennessee Houston Jacksonville Cleveland St Louis Arizona Philly (though I guess Foles "could' belong in the above tier, but I'll be honest he's in this group because I haven't seen much of him, and he hasn't been a starter for long). Washington Minnesota Tampa Bay __________________ Last edited by CoMoChief; 09-04-2014 at 02:28 AM..
Posts: 39,245