The fumble reversal was the right call.
For some reason (Mike Carey), everyone decided that the elbow is what mattered. The elbow is not needed. If Caldwell's forearm touches the ground before the ball moves, he is down. Here are 2 pictures, one while Caldwell is not down, and one right as his forearm touches the ground. The ball is in the same position relative to Caldwell.
The ball does not move, so he has control still, and is down. No fumble.
Oh, and the NFL agrees with me.
https://twitter.com/DeanBlandino/sta...64873497796608