|
I cant believe with this and the other thread, I am reading the slander about Andrew Luck in an attempt to prop up Alex (yes Hootie, I am aware you wouldnt take Alex over Luck). But the point that Luck had an awful year is just a joke.
Luck has a terrible offensive line, one of if not the worst rushing offense in the NFL, and a terrible defense. The Colts literally ARE Andrew Luck.
The entire success of that franchise is predicated on Luck being able to carry them....can the same be said about Alex Smith?
If Andrew Luck doesnt play well, the Colts lose....can the same be said about Alex Smith?
If the Colts defense gives up 24 points, Andrew Luck still gives them a chance to win.....can the same be said about Alex Smith?
Andrew Luck is asked to do sooooo much more than Alex is, its comical. Alex is not asked to do more by Reid (and he wasn't by Harbaugh). Why? Because chances are, he would revert back to pre-Harbaugh days where he was one of the worst QBs in the NFL. The Chiefs passing offense is a low powered, dink and dunk offense, because it runs in a way which Alex can be successful (which I firmly believe most NFL quarterbacks could replicate). Luck runs a high powered passing offense, because he is capable of leading one.
There is absolutely no comparison between Alex and Luck. Zero.
|