Quote:
Originally Posted by Just Passin' By
Of course you don't see many names. You were asking for a very small subset of players/teams. By only equating success with a SB win, you're starting with a max of 49 situations, right from the start. Then, coupling that with the specific weaknesses mentioned:
Bad OL
Bad WR
you naturally will get an even smaller number.
|
That's not what I was doing. I was asking for QBs that excelled (or played at a high level) while having both shit at OL and WR.
Give me a year where Ben truly excelled, and didn't have more than shit for OL and WRs.
Same for the others. That is the level of specificity I was truly hoping for.
Ben didn't really excel until 2007.. where really, the only thing he could have been said to do very well in was throwing 32 TD passes. However, he had a young and very good Santonio Holmes at that time... plus Hines Ward.. and throw in Heath Miller. The 4 yrs after 2007, he was solid but not putting up grand numbers. They drafted Mike Wallace for him in 2000, and he was great in the early years. Antonio Brown is a top 5 WR in the league... no?
Would these receivers not remove him from the list?