Yeah I mean it all depends on what criteria you use. And since it's Rany's list and he's doing all the work, he can use whatever criteria he wants.
But in terms of sheer emotional impact it has to be Salvy's hit.
My top 10 Royals plays of all time in terms of emotional impact:
- Dane Iorg
- Salvy's hit
- Hos's Dash
- Gordon's HR
- Brett's 3 run homer in 1980
- Kendrys off Correa
- Cain's dash
- Motley's 2 run homer, after hitting one just foul, in game 7
- Donaldson's ground out to end the ALCS
- Sundberg's triple off the top of the wall in the 1985 ALCS