[Discuss Thrower]

Originally Posted by Buehler445

Makes sense Discuss. I can see that but she still should have told Jon that she is trying to get help from her (not their) cousin in the Vale.

Like I said, in black and white thinking: if she believed that LF was going to come through at the time she was talking with Jon about the battle plan, then yes -she got people needlessly killed. If she had any reasonable doubt that it wasn't going to happen then she's justified in keeping quiet. From that perspective it goes down two ways backing up why she stays quiet: 1) He shows up with the Army of the Vale, they wreck shit and Winterfell is reclaimed by the Starks but with political ramifications, or 2) Baelish doesn't come through but Jon / Davos structure their battle plan on their arrival at a certain time (since you'd assume that she'd have any idea of when they'd arrive given her communications with LF) but ultimately does not, creating an even bigger tactical failure.