Quote:
Originally Posted by Reerun_KC
I have to agree with this post....
Where is the QB Guru and Offensive Genius that we have heard so much about?
We are in year 4 and can barely function as an offense...
|
At some point, one must ponder; is perhaps Reid's "offensive philosophy" pure shit?
What if Alex Smith IS the "right man" for the job, and the "job" itself isn't worth two ****s?
A LOT can happen in a decade.
What would happen if you stacked 75% of the entire offense with pro bowl talent and drafted a sure-fire franchise QB who bought in to Andy's offensive philosophy? Would the end result be any different?
Or, you keep the above scenario and somehow manage to acquire a PROVEN franchise QB like Rodgers? Would the end-result be any different?
Now I would argue that the best QB for Andy is the one who takes the offense right out of his chubby little hands, one who like Peyton had the experience and skill to run his own offensive scheme and the talent to back it up and to produce. Not an outright rebel against the coach but one who has the ability to say, at the LOS, "nope, we're not running that screen" and change the plays as needed.
Reid needs a QB who is better than HE is, not a marching worker-ant mindlessly taking orders. Because it seems to me, that being on the "same page" with Andy during the heat of battle may not necessarily be the best place for the offense overall to be.