Quote:
Originally Posted by BigRedChief
|
Elledge seems to low but that's understandable since the Mariners slow-played him. He needs time in AA to move up the lists much.
Williams is too high, IMO and Cabrera is too low. I'd put Capel at 9, Cabrera at 10, Roberts 11 and then Williams at 12.
But that's parsing things pretty thinly for a prospect list. I mean I'd move Fernandez, Woodford and Urias down 5-6 spots/each as well (maybe 10 spots for Fernandez. He's nearing non-entity status for me) and that would get Elledge up into the high teens and move Gingery up as well.
But man, that big ol' bunch of young pitchers in the 20s or so is just pretty fluid. I don't think you can argue too loudly over any of them and I suspect most of them will be off the list in a year or so anyway. Guys like Oviedo and Seijas stall out and fade away pretty quickly.