Quote:
Originally Posted by Chris Meck
He's more talented without question.
But the whole team has been so undisciplined, it's hard to tell what the **** is actually going on.
You might literally be better off going with the less talented, more scheme disciplined player in Dalton.
To be fair, I watched two Dallas games this season, but in both I was just struck by the fact that half the time I couldn't even tell what they were trying to do. It was like street ball.
Dak clearly has a lot of physical talent. More than most. But he's not been running an NFL offense with any efficiency. It's pretty ****ed up.
Can he? Well, yeah, maybe. Garrett was clearly a shit coach, and his entire team was entirely undisciplined.
Maybe that can change with McCarthy; at least I don't ever remember GB being street-ballers.
But Dalton is a mid-level NFL starting QB. He's Alex Smith, more or less. It's possible that you might get better results with THAT than Dak unless Dak can adjust to a disciplined offense.
|
Well, the competition might force Dak to grow up a little and that's probably a big reason Dalton was signed. Mccarthy studied up a ton on modern offenses in his off year and i can't imagine he doesn't borrow from Reid's playbook. If he's smart he'll design the offense for Dak to play with less structure just as Reid did. I agree I'm a little skeptical he can fix all of Dak. But It's kind of the Alex Smith debate all over again. Except you have a worse version of Alex Smith and you have the high upside qb already on your roster. Sure you can go safe but id much rather roll the dice.