Quote:
Originally Posted by TwistedChief
This is such a ridiculous argument. You’re using a sample size of 6 games when Brady walked into a better situation and Belichick was left with a worse situation to pass judgment on two decades of evidence.
They’re both exceptional talents at what they do. Both possibly the greatest ever in their respective roles. They helped each other.
But if you really want to get into it, what do you think the Patriots record would be if Brady stayed and Belichick left? And what would Tampa’s record be if the Bucs had Belichick as their head coach and let’s say Jimmy G as their QB?
Pretty sure your conclusion would be different then.
|
In 7 seasons without Tom Brady, Bill has won an average of 7 games. That includes his 11-5 season in Cleveland and the season with Cassel but does not include this current season since it isn't complete.
It would be one thing if he were an above-500 coach without Brady but he's not.
The NFL revolves around QB's. Is Bill a great coach? Absolutely. But without Brady, he's not a champion.
Just like Andy is not a champion without Mahomes.
QB's are the cake, coaches are the frosting.