Quote:
Originally Posted by ChiefsFanatic
Honestly, I think Schottenheimer was a better head coach than Reid. Until Reid landed Mahomes, he was basically the offensive version of the defensive Schottenheimer.
When Marty had a legitimate star QB, he went to the AFC Championship game. Peterson is responsible for the quarterbacks Marty had to work with, and Peterson was responsible for deciding that Nick Lowery was too expensive, and going with that POS kicker who will not be named. If Peterson had just paid Lowery, that 95 team probably wins the SB with the #1 defense in football.
I am not saying that Marty was more successful, because Reid obviously has the ring, but without Mahomes, Reid doesn't even get us to a single AFC Championship game. Hell, other than Montana, Alex Smith was better than any QB Carl Peterson ever signed for Marty.
Sent from my GM1915 using Tapatalk
|
I mean you make a couple of reasonable points but don't forget that Marty benched Rich Gannon for Elvis Grbac for another 1 and done playoff game. He keeps Gannon we probably win the Superbowl that year. Gannon didn't put up amazing stats that year but I remember watching and he was good for us. That was a terrible coaching decision. Reid also went to 3 NFC championship games with the Eagles and 1 Superbowl, ya McNabb was good and of course Mahomes is amazing but still.
Reid also came to KC after we earned the #1 draft pick on a pretty bad talent year for the draft and we immediately went to the playoffs with alex smith