[Baby Lee]

Not going to delve into the merits of the OP itself, but I am curious about this dynamic where people criticize a specific aspect of someone's skillset and people immediately go to the narrative that it's a criticism of their entire existence.

People have criticized Reid in various specific ways over the years, he doesn't pound the rock, he has trouble with time management, he flubs challenges, . . . here it's about the strategy of a highly specific situation.

If people had posted that Reid is not very good at sculpted abs, or cum-gutter hips, would you immediately jump to 'he's a HoF coach, I think he's the most fit, healthy and muscularly toned person in history? Why don't you root for a team with a meathead gym rat like Sean McVay, loser?!?!'

This goes a lot wider than the issue of Reid, it's a debating dynamic I've seen on the rise in a number of venues, and am curious if anyone else has defense or criticism, or championing or denial, or whatever, of it.