Quote:
Originally Posted by staylor26
I haven't seen a single person suggest that McDuffie "isn't ready yet", because nobody is that stupid.
He's a rookie. There will be some ups and downs, and I don't doubt that he's been beat quite a bit too at camp, but your take reeks of bullshit unwarranted pessimism.
The majority of noise about McDuffie, especially as of late, has been overwhelmingly positive.
We've all also seen clips of him throughout TC. His coverage is almost always sticky, and he has 4 really nice PBUs the last 2 days.
But again, your evaluation based on 1 on 1s ins a single practice is the gospel! You get to write the book of Trent McDuffie now!
|
There you go. There’s the exchange of information that characterizes a syllogism. Now we can have an actual discussion.
And, to what you’ve said, fair point. He’s made some plays, he made one today. But that doesn’t explain his performance today in both 1v1s and team drills, which was not remotely sticky. Williams and Sneed stick. McDuffie did not today, and it wasn’t close.
Now that’s fine if he’s lighting up PAC 12, but this is a new beast. He did not display recovery speed, a major problem. He gets boxed out and beaten to a spot. He’s grabby.
This doesn’t kill McDuffie in the crib, but those are going to be lingering issues that simply being a rookie will only partially repair.
I’m a big fan of drafting him and I like his skillset. But today’s practice was problematic to me.