[AdolfOliverBush]

Originally Posted by Megatron96

Lot of ways to think about this. But if I'm thinking I need to win one game, say the SB, and I can pick any QB I want, then probably in this order:

Mahomes
Allen
Hurts
Burrow
Tua
Herbert
Aaron Rodgers
Cousins
Dak
Jackson

Top-5 are pretty much in order. Tua is having a better season than Herbert right now, but obviously Herbert has the more elite physical abilities. Call it a coinflip at 5 & 6.

I'd take a healthy AR over any of the last three QBs just based on ability, and he's won a SB, so 7 is pretty set.

Cousins and Dak are kind of the same guy, in that both are better than average QBs, that can't carry a team based just on their individual abilities, but if surrounded by enough talent on both sides of the ball, they both can be very successful. So, either one could be 8 or 9.

Lamar. Not even certain he should be included at all in the top-10, but based just on his running ability, I can't think of another QB that I'd trust more of the remaining 22 QBs to at least keep me in the game and give me a chance to win.

It's interesting that besides Mahomes, the only QB on that list who has accomplished a damn thing is Rodgers.