Nothing personal Clay, but just the fact you make this comparison tells me you never played the game.
I don't care how athletic or big gunned a QB is, IF he never learns to play chess at the QB position in the NFL and continues to play checkers he will just be JAAQB(Just Another Athletic QB) with a limited mind thus limiting his athleticism in the long run in the NFL. And we have witnessed many, many of those in the last 20yrs. Very few have had the whole package. Aaron Rodgers had what Peyton and Tom did not have, a big arm and athleticism but all played great chess.
We are now blessed as a fanbase to be presently witnessing 'thee best NFL QB' of all time(barring injury and future bad drafts) taking the NFL QB position to a whole new level
playing backyard football at the chess level"never seen before". Aaron's backyard ball doesn't even come close to Pat IMO